Re:Immutable Data Structures That Are Compatible with Normal...
by Rotareti on Sunday August 13, 2017 @08:10AM
(#15002590)
I totally agree with you. I wish we had a built-in immutable array type and a built-in immutable object type. I love the way it's done in Python, where you have Lists vs Tuples and Class Objects vs NamedTuples. You can consume them the same way:
my_list = [1,2,3] # mutable
my_tuple = (1,2,3) # immutable
my_clsobj = myclass(foo=1, bar=2) # mutable
my_namedt = mynamedt(foo=1, bar=2) # immutable
my_list[0] # 1
my_tuple[0] # 1
my_clsobj.foo # 1
my_namedt.foo # 1
Re:Immutable Data Structures That Are Compatible with Normal...
by macintux on Sunday August 13, 2017 @02:08PM
(#15004065)
More generally, this is why I don't find languages that add "functional" features very compelling.
Behavior is so well-defined in a functional system that it's intensely frustrating dealing with any imperative/OO language.
The thing I like about immutability in languages that implement it by design is that you know that if you get an data structure, it is immutable. In the world of javascript, you not only have to worry about whether an object you get from a library is immutable, but which kind of immutable implementation is using. Moreover, that information is not easily available in the type signatures, so you have to go to the library author's documentation, if any! That, to me, is a complete mess.