News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by AdmiralAsshat on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:38PM (#14998593)
It was folly to think that YouTube would be a safe place to document war crimes. YouTube is a distribution channel, not a preservation channel. Its ease of use certainly makes it an attractive option to upload things quickly, but anything of historical significance should have the video raws immediately turned over to a human rights organization for preservation.
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by ballenf on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:59PM (#14998721)
Youtube used to be a distribution channel but it slowly became an ad delivery tool with content along for the ride. Like 99% of other free (and even some paid) internet sites.

Either way, totally agree that it's a tragic situation.

The only sympathy I have for Google is that trying to separate the good vs. "evil" (as in "Don't be evil.") content is a monumental task that machine learning will probably never be capable of performing. So they're left with the choice of spending an inordinate amount on human review and detailed research or just make wildly over-broad removals.

I'd rather they leave up more rather than less, but they tried this approach and it almost lost them every major advertiser. So continuing down that road would potentially lead to the whole platform losing viability. Maybe some would like that outcome but these historical videos would be just as lost.

Maybe we'll see the pendulum swing back in an effort to reach a more reasonable middle ground.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by wbl on Saturday August 12, 2017 @01:30PM (#14998882)
It's hopeless for people. Is that footage of ISIS burning a prisoner alive evidence of war crimes or propaganda? How about both! Ban child nudity and depictions of cruelty to children: you've just banned a Pulitzer prize winning photograph from the Vietnam war.
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by nxc18 on Saturday August 12, 2017 @01:09PM (#14998777)
Google has an inordinate amount of money to spend on inordinate amount of content review. Deleting history and evidence of war crimes is Evil; good thing Google had abandoned their earlier aspirations.
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by jptman on Saturday August 12, 2017 @02:02PM (#14999020)
I think you are underestimating the amount of video that gets uploaded to Youtube. Smaller sites may be better at stuff like this but that's solely because they don't have quite the amount of content. Hundreds of hours of videos are uploaded per minute. They may eventually have AI good enough to do a better job, but this is an unprecedented amount of content to review.
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by CaptSpify on Saturday August 12, 2017 @04:51PM (#14999893)
So?

If youtube can't handle the load, then they shouldn't claim that they can. At the absolute lest, they need a usable appeals process. If they can't do that, then they need to own up to it, and stop allowing anyone to upload anything.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by koide on Saturday August 12, 2017 @05:46PM (#15000183)
Sorry, but why? Google owns nobody anything. If you have war crime evidence or other important content to publish, upload it to YouTube and all other video sites, letting archive.org and other human rights organizations in the loop. You can put the press in the mix as well.
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by CaptSpify on Saturday August 12, 2017 @06:19PM (#15000334)
Because it's a shitty thing to do, and we shouldn't encourage shitty behavior? Just because they want to take the cheap and lazy route doesn't mean that we can't criticize them for it.
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by fastball on Sunday August 13, 2017 @09:33AM (#15002839)
Why? Own up to what?

YouTube is a company that is beholden to advertisers. YouTube wants/pays for videos that they can put ads in front of. If your content is not the type of content YouTube can wrap in ads, and you need longevity for your videos, YouTube is not the platform for you. YouTube never claimed to be an everlasting video storage space for all your video needs, so I'm not sure why you're expecting that of them.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by Kequc on Sunday August 13, 2017 @11:08AM (#15003191)
It's in part because that is what Google has done in the past. They give you unlimited space to store your photos, your email, and your data, why wouldn't you expect to be able to store video.

Video has become politicised because it is a popular medium for political topics and one which can be rapidly produced and consumed. Advertisers are perhaps influencing Google's decisions on this, but they are equally political. The debacle with the diversity memo is one example of biases inside of the company. There have been many more examples over the last years, one such example is censorship across the board of conservative commentators.

It goes on in Facebook, Twitter and so on. So we have to wait for competitors to turn up, how many years will that take? Is that a responsible route considering the foothold these companies have?

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by fastball on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:27AM (#15008757)
Yes, absolutely, you have to wait for a competitor to turn up. Or you can build a platform yourself, it's not difficult to do, especially in 2017. Hosting is cheap, video codecs are open source, there are a lot of companies that are willing to negotiate advertising partnerships. YouTube is a private businesses, fuck your privilege.

ALSO: I don't know about you, but this so-called "censoring" of conservative commentators doesn't seem to have worked. I see more young people skewing right/centre than I did 10 years ago. You can call it censorship if you want (because sure, that's probably the best term), but implying that a company selectively hosting content is the same thing as limiting the free exercise of speech is absurd.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by cabalamat on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:34AM (#15008825)
> I see more young people skewing right/centre than I did 10 years ago.

Probably for this reason: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/04/22/right-is-the-new-left/

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by ikeboy on Saturday August 12, 2017 @04:05PM (#14999694)
Leave them up, but remove ads?
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by davidreiss on Sunday August 13, 2017 @08:40AM (#15002669)
> The only sympathy I have for Google is that trying to separate the good vs. "evil" (as in "Don't be evil.") content is a monumental task that machine learning will probably never be capable of performing

That's an impossibility because evil depends on perspective.

This is why we have free speech rights in america. If we determined others to limit our free speech by their perception of evil, then atheist speech and lgbt speech would be banned. Pornography would be banned along with "offensive" music. Hell books like huckleberry finn would be banned.

This is why we cherish free speech rights in america ( or we used to ) and why we have the saying "You have the right to be offended".

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by osteele on Saturday August 12, 2017 @02:21PM (#14999147)
One issue with YouTube is archival status. Another is provenance.

At some point it will be as easy to create fake videos as to create fake text. It is unrealistic to expect people who aren't information literate about text will be literate about video, but I hope that there's a way for journalists to move away from YouTube by then.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by Too on Sunday August 13, 2017 @03:40AM (#15001964)
This is already happening.

I was googling for baking videos the other day, when all of the sudden most of the hits I got was auto generated videos uploaded on youtube. They just had some panning stock photos in the background with text scrolling on top and super generic music, must be really simple to generate.

There were hundreds, maybe even thousands, of them from various accounts, all conveniently linked to each other making more of them appear as relevant in the rightmost column.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by eloisius on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:48PM (#14998654)
I doubt they're grieving lost footage. It's loss of access to that distribution channel.

Documentation is pointless if it can't be distributed and used to effect change.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by privong on Saturday August 12, 2017 @01:04PM (#14998752)
> I doubt they're grieving lost footage.

This comment by jacobr suggests there is a risk of lost footage: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14998452

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by ComodoHacker on Saturday August 12, 2017 @02:37PM (#14999244)
>should have the video raws immediately turned over to a human rights organization for preservation

You're saying like every human rights organization have some magical means of preservation other than uploading to YouTube.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by PeterisP on Saturday August 12, 2017 @04:05PM (#14999693)
Something like a computer with a hard drive or an USB memory stick?
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by fastball on Sunday August 13, 2017 @09:41AM (#15002860)
If it's so important than maybe, yes, these orgs should have some means other than YouTube.

If it's so important, these orgs should maybe build their own platform that is purely about video longevity.

Expecting a private company to host content they don't want to host is silly.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by Mangalor on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:54PM (#14998688)
Where else should they be stored?
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by sologoub on Saturday August 12, 2017 @07:20PM (#15000598)
How about a public s3 bucket curated by a non-profit?

Tools exist already to upload to S3 from practically every device, especially Android.

Curation would be much harder, but there is a lot of money in philanthropy and I could see some deep pockets contributing to that.

YouTube is fine as a means of promoting and gaining awareness - world should know about these things, but it's not rational to expect a corporation (aka people within it) to act in any other interest other then it's own.

Seems like this could be an interesting infrastructure non-profit for YC to fund.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by Sir_Cmpwn on Saturday August 12, 2017 @12:56PM (#14998701)
archive.org
Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by osteele on Saturday August 12, 2017 @02:29PM (#14999183)
I hope we're in a world where that can happen.

At the least, we probably need “upload video to archive.org” mobile apps to make this as useful to journalists in the field as YouTube currently is.

If the Archive grows as a journalistic distribution channel, it might then face YouTube's issues of copyrights, piracy, and other criminal use. However, the Archive could apply goals that are more compatible with journalism than YouTube can. Maybe sufficient philanthropic support could make this possible.

Re:YouTube AI deletes war crimes evidence as 'extremist mate... by moogly on Saturday August 12, 2017 @02:24PM (#14999164)
liveleak