Near me there's a mixed-use cycleway alongside a main road (put in 10-15 years ago). Driveways cross it regularly and you have to stop at every side-road to cross, but the big problem is commercial buildings with lowered kerbs and driveways. We have a drive-through restaurant, two car washes and a business park. Cycling along there is lethal because the drivers don't look before turning in or coming out. I choose to cycle on the road because while annoying drivers I feel safer.
The modal shares of cycling in the Netherlands or Denmark (segregated provision) vs, say, the UK or US (largely no distinct provision) are a pretty clear indicator that segregation gets more people cycling. If the collateral damage is that a few roadies have to slow down and use bike lanes in cities, I'm not uncomfortable with that, even speaking as a confident on-road cyclist myself.
Perhaps, but I think it's worth recognizing that, counterintuitively, a bad bike lane can be worse than no bike lane.
> The modal shares of cycling in the Netherlands or Denmark (segregated provision) vs, say, the UK or US (largely no distinct provision) are a pretty clear indicator that segregation gets more people cycling.
Not convinced; there are many differences between these countries. I've heard it argued that e.g. much greater legal liability for drivers who injure or kill cyclists is what makes the difference.
While it's no big deal for experienced cyclists, mixing with motor traffic on busy roads is a big psychological barrier for those who are new and less-experienced.
For that reason, distinct cycle lanes, when built to a sufficiently high standard, result in significant increases in cycle uptake. More cyclists on the road means more safety for everyone, because drivers are more likely to look out for (and behave more considerately towards) cyclists when there are more of them about and cycling becomes "normalised".
Of course, none of this is an excuse for building crappy, useless cycle lanes. We have enough of those in the UK. Thankfully things are improving: London is worlds away from where it was even 5 years ago thanks to investments in infrastructure that is genuinely safe and useful.
Hopefully some of the best new cycle infrastructure there (the new Cycle Superhighway along Victoria Embankment to Tower Hill, for example) can serve as a model for future investments in other UK cities.
I disagree, if I can cycle far away from the road, than I happily avoid all the smell, noise and danger.
But sure, where I have to use the road, I'd like it to be as safe as possible ...
This matches a lot of my experience in Britain. When there's a cycle lane alongside a road drivers will often get aggressive about you cycling in the main roadway, even when (as is so often the case) the cycle lane is unsafe or unsuitable.
IMO we should focus less on distinct cycling routes, and more on making road junctions safer for cyclists.