Re:McSweeney's response to the Google Memo
by Veedrac on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @05:49PM
(#14974020)
Am I right in concluding that this is just humour, and not actually taking a stance of any kind on the issue?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:McSweeney's response to the Google Memo
by zaphods-towel on Thursday August 10, 2017 @11:34AM
(#14980717)
It certainly is taking a stance (but keep in mind that this is an individual writer whose submission was accepted by McSweeneys rather than a piece by the editors). It's mocking the memo and it's also pointing out the importance of human issues. It's pointing out that corporations are tools created by and for people, and ignoring human concerns is foolish.
Re:McSweeney's response to the Google Memo
by lobotryas on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @06:27PM
(#14974332)
Of course this is taking a stance. By mocking the assumed contents of the memo this post, in essence, is a straw-man attack on the memo and its author that doesn't intellectually engage with either.
Re:McSweeney's response to the Google Memo
by Veedrac on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @06:36PM
(#14974394)
I can't work out how this could be a strawman though; the arguments it gives are far _stronger_ than the original. The only indication that it might be satire is that it's funny, and that's hardly a sufficient argument.
Re:McSweeney's response to the Google Memo
by tcbawo on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @07:11PM
(#14974630)
Maybe not a straw man, but rather an attempt to frame the question in a way that is less likely to cause people to be angry or defensive.
It doesn't seem to take a side, but rather encourage further debate.
Re:McSweeney's response to the Google Memo
by confounded on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @06:34PM
(#14974378)
It is quite funny though (which I believe is the point).