News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Google memo isn’t sexist or anti-diversity, it’s science by tptacek on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @10:49AM (#14969546)
You haven't so much responded to my comment as used it as a coat rack to hang an unrelated argument on. I didn't cite Zunger's blog post and don't really understand why people like it so much. I'd prefer not to discuss it here, and thank you in advance for not demanding I do so.
Re:The Google memo isn’t sexist or anti-diversity, it’s science by monktastic1 on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @10:57AM (#14969640)
If that's what I did, I didn't mean to. I was primarily addressing your opening paragraph:

> It picks out a small subset of the claims made in the document, discards the context and all the other claims, and then harangues us for having a problem with "science".

I'm claiming that the reason she does this is because it is the number one point cited by many of the detractors, and it prevents us from getting into the more interesting and relevant questions.

Re:The Google memo isn’t sexist or anti-diversity, it’s science by tptacek on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @11:02AM (#14969723)
If you want to suggest that Debrah Soh blundered by expanding a rebuttal to Yonatan Zunger's piece into a broader defense of the very dumb "anti-diversity memo", I am prepared to stipulate that. Like I said: while I may be on the same side as Zunger, I found his blog post shrill and unpersuasive. He had the facts on his side, but didn't know where to look for them, and waved his hands instead.