Here's an example of how accounting is hard with differences between US GAAP and IFRS [1]. Uber loses half it's revenue under a new US GAAP principle...
[1] https://www.ft.com/content/74447ca2-6b0b-11e7-bfeb-33fe0c5b7...
In all fairness, a bunch of people are paying a little too much, while a small minority are getting most of the benefit, e.g. people who default on their loan, or who drive the car into the ground in three months and then return it. But, that in a nutshell is why sub-prime leases are really expensive on the open, non-VC-subsidized market to begin with.
The fact is, the vehicle portion of a hack business is a non-negligible portion of the cost. Most professional drivers replace their car every 2-3 years, after driving the old one to near-zero value by putting 150k+ miles on it. UberX's pricing is pretty much predicated on the fact that people aren't sophisticated enough to amortize their vehicle cost into their profit calculation. Works fine, until you kill your first car and it's time to buy a new one to keep driving ...
We're all paying much less for car rides than we were a few years ago, but the basic underlying cost of providing those rides has not changed much at all.
(Not literally me, I never used Blue Apron, but a lot of people have)
The drivers that exit the lease early benefit in that they are able to without huge penalty. They didn't net much out of the whole relationship though. How much do they make a day after subtracting $17/day just for the vehicle, plus whatever fuel costs are, self employment tax, commercial insurance, etc?
For drivers that keep the car for a long time, the subprime terms eat into an already paltry income. That was the portion of drivers I meant weren't benefiting.
- for those who returned the car after months, this is an option that just isn't available in an ordinary lease - in some cases, death is not enough to cancel a lease. These folks would have been left making all of the payments on the car for the rest of the term. Plus, ordinary leases have very low mileage caps. They may not have made much money, but they would have lost thousands if they had a conventional lease.
- for those who keep the car say 3 years and put on 200k miles: they would pay a total of $18k and return the car with a couple thousand dollars of value. If the purchase price was say $22k, then they got a completely fair deal.
That's the thing - I don't think the terms were sub-prime at all, they were simply priced to only appeal to serious professional drivers working 50-60 hours and 1500 miles per week, which is not atypical for cabbies and limo drivers (mileage might even be low).
https://www.uber.com/drive/vehicle-solutions/leasing/
"The majority of eligible vehicles will be pre-leased and/or pre-owned inventory"
I think they also wanted to reserve the right to re-lease cars that came back as early returns under the leasing plan.