News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quit quirks when working with others by masklinn on Thursday July 08, 2010 @02:24AM (#1496655)
> The correct way to accomplish 'Off' is 'Pause' followed by 'now wait a while' --which I consider an extremely clumsy move on Apple's part (not the behaviour, which is fine once you discover it, but how un-, and even counter-, intuitive it is).

But that wouldn't be "off", that would be "hibernate". Which is what you want most of the time.

Off would be a complete power off, and it makes sense that the device's state is not saved to NAND (because most people won't ever need that). The configuration wasn't changed was it?

It's the same with e.g. an iPhone, a quick tap of the power button shuts down the screen, a long tap completely shuts off the device. Most people never ever need to completely shut it off.

Re:Quit quirks when working with others by JadeNB on Thursday July 08, 2010 @12:40PM (#1497882)
> But that wouldn't be "off", that would be "hibernate". Which is what you want most of the time.

I agree, and, indeed, I think the behaviour, once discovered, is perfectly sensible; I'm just talking about the initial discovery experience.

The manual (at http://manuals.info.apple.com/en/ipod_shuffle_features_guide...) does not use the terminology you mention; instead, it refers at the top of the chart on p. 4 to 'Turn[ing] iPod off', then at the bottom of the same chart to 'Reset[ting] iPod' (both by pushing the slider to 'Off'!); and it does not mention 'Hibernation' (or equivalent terminology), or the fact that it should replace complete power down, at all.

Re:Quit quirks when working with others by masklinn on Friday July 09, 2010 @07:43AM (#1500348)
> I agree, and, indeed, I think the behaviour, once discovered, is perfectly sensible; I'm just talking about the initial discovery experience.

The initial discovery experience, for most people, is that you don't do anything and you iPod "magically" does the right thing in return.

Re:Quit quirks when working with others by JadeNB on Friday July 09, 2010 @10:44AM (#1500755)
> The initial discovery experience, for most people, is that you don't do anything and you iPod "magically" does the right thing in return.

I think that, at this point, we're getting into anecdotal evidence; I don't have any idea what most people's iPod experience is, but certainly it's not natural to me to conclude my experience with an electronic device simply by walking away from itβ€”I want to turn it off. (The fact that computers are an exception perhaps explains why a younger generation might be more inclined to the 'just walk away' approach. EDIT: OK, and cell phones. But I still think that I have more devices in my life that I turn off than devices that I don't. :-) )

My main evidence that this is not the only obvious approach is that it is different to the behaviour of the iPod Shuffle 1G, which one did (or at least could) put into hibernation by sliding the main switch to 'Off'. It was this change between generations that particularly confused me.