News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why isn't there a general purpose visual programming lang... by Jun8 on Thursday July 08, 2010 @01:49AM (#1496601)
An analogy with natural languages may be useful: there are no languages without syntax, i.e. no completely visual (ideographic) ones, except for simplistic signage domains, e.g. signs in airports, traffic signs, etc. The reason for this is: if you push aside syntax, there is very little expressive power left in a language. The prog lang space mirrors this behavior well, I think: you have very specialized languages, like kudo, but developing a visual language with enough expressive power to be general is very hard, not to say impossible.

I didn't understand your point about a "programming environment"

Re:Why isn't there a general purpose visual programming lang... by andrewtj on Thursday July 08, 2010 @03:03AM (#1496698)
The comparison you asked for is that of an apple and an orange. I think you may have also misunderstood my comment on syntax — I wrote "removing syntax as a source of errors" not "remove syntax".
Re:Why isn't there a general purpose visual programming lang... by extension on Thursday July 08, 2010 @06:20AM (#1496950)
But then aren't you just replacing syntax errors with "why can't I attach this visual thingy to that visual thingy"?

Either way, they the essence of what they need to learn is the same: translate their ideas into a weird language. I'm not convinced that fitting shapes together is more helpful in that regard than a parser with good error messages and an IDE that does syntax coloring and code completion.

Re:Why isn't there a general purpose visual programming lang... by andrewtj on Thursday July 08, 2010 @06:43AM (#1496983)
But then aren't you just replacing syntax errors with "why can't I attach this visual thingy to that visual thingy"?

Yes — the idea being to replace syntax and/or logic errors with just logic errors.

Either way, they the essence of what they need to learn is the same: translate their ideas into a weird language. I'm not convinced that fitting shapes together is more helpful in that regard than a parser with good error messages and an IDE that does syntax coloring and code completion.

I seem to be the only one for whom the words "visual programming" don't conjure an image of weird shapes and diagrams — but I've already said that http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1496529