Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by gaius on Thursday July 08, 2010 @07:53AM
(#1497067)
Yes, the alternative to this is the patent scheme the pharma industry uses. Think about it - a drug may be trivially simple to manufacture, the hard part is developing it in the first place then shepherding it through the FDA approval process. So they rely on patents because secrecy at that scale is impossible.
For an example closer to home, did you never wonder how RMS working alone was able to put Symbolics out of business? Because he waited for them to discover what users wanted, the hard part, then he simply copied the implementation and gave it away for free. If they'd gone stealth, maybe we'd all be using LispM's today. Now we'll never know.
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by steve19 on Thursday July 08, 2010 @08:06AM
(#1497082)
If one guy working from a closet at MIT can destroy your multi-million dollar business, then you are in the wrong business.
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by gaius on Thursday July 08, 2010 @09:22AM
(#1497207)
You've completely missed my point. The hard part is NOT the coding. It's knowing what to code, what features your users want. Symbolics did the hard part, RMS merely copied what they (market) researched. Like the way anyone can make a copy of a DVD once a studio has actually made the film.
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by rmc on Friday July 09, 2010 @06:04AM
(#1500240)
Movie studios are in the business of making movies, plural. Just cause I can copy DVDs once and set up a DVD burning shop doesn't mean I can make the next movie. Movie studios have the process and equipment (cameras, sets), contacts (directors, actors) to make movies.
If the hardest part of your business can be so easily copied by someone else, then you do have a problem. If it can't be copied then you might not have a problem
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by gaius on Friday July 09, 2010 @08:51AM
(#1500432)
Similarly, as demonstrated by the fact that we aren't all using LispM's today, Stallman could copy features from Symbolics but he couldn't compete per se, as he had no way of doing the hard part, which was figuring out what the end users wanted.
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by pwim on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @09:00PM
(#1496096)
Is there really any software you can build in hours or days and return vast sums of money? If you have a really specific market, I would imagine even if the software itself was simple, the challenge would be marketing it to that group.
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by jason_tko on Wednesday July 07, 2010 @10:08PM
(#1496217)
If there is, he's probably not going to tell you about it. :)
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by mikecane on Thursday July 08, 2010 @08:30AM
(#1497119)
Exactly: Like some guy who creates software that wins a lottery or horse races or whatever and is raking it in. What incentive does he have to share that with anybody?
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by blub on Thursday July 08, 2010 @02:53AM
(#1496687)
Someone from the Joel on Software forums has actually copied his bingo idea. This was a couple of years ago I think.
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by patio11 on Thursday July 08, 2010 @11:30AM
(#1497654)
Someone from the Joel on Software forums has actually copied his bingo idea.
Twice.
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by noelsequeira on Thursday July 08, 2010 @05:19PM
(#1498817)
So, in hindsight would you change anything / be a tad more secretive? I'm guessing you wouldn't, but would love to hear your take.
Re:Ask HN: If ideas are worthless, why are some startups in ...
by Gormo on Thursday July 08, 2010 @11:48AM
(#1497720)
Unless, of course, you are able to adapt to openness, and compensate for its costs by taking advantage of its benefits. If you can grow despite this handicap, you have an enormous competitive advantage against those who would collapse if their secrets were revealed.
Intentionally doing things the hard way can sometimes make you much more resilient, as long as you reach the endgame in one piece.
As usual, I'll give Patrick of Bingo Card Creator as my example. He has been completely transparent with us guys about what he's doing and how he's doing it. We have a complete blueprint for how to compete with him. None of us are going to bother, because it's a very small market opportunity and Patrick's business relies upon generating lots of data, lots of inbound links and the Googley momentum that comes with it.
Imagine if his position was slightly different. Imagine if Patrick had discovered that a very specific group of people were prepared to pay him good money for very trivial software. There are plenty of examples if you go looking for them - software that took days or hours to develop but that sells for serious money because it solves a real business problem in a low-tech industry. The value in the business is the domain knowledge needed to identify the market need.
If you're selling a web app to nerds, then stealth mode makes no sense. You need to engage with your market as quickly as possible, and chances are that someone is developing the same product anyway.
If you've spent good time and money on researching potential market opportunities, you'd be a total idiot to give away the results of that effort just because it's the done thing. I love getting to see the innards of so many businesses, but it makes me cringe at the stuff people will make public.
I don't think many of us realise that the rest of the business world considers our culture of openness to be absolutely fucking crazy. Just look at Apple - not even Jony Ive is allowed to speak freely. We see that as weird and Orwellian, but the rest of the business world calls it "not blabbing all our trade secrets to the press".