Re:It's not you, it's your books
by SteveC on Saturday March 29, 2008 @02:52PM
(#149567)
I'm always suspicious of adults who list Harry Potter as their favourite book.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Agreed.
Adults who list Harry Potter as their favorite book (which is not the same as admitting Harry Potter is a fun read) by doing so fairly explicitly state that the universe of a children's book, however well written it is, is pretty much all the intellectual stimulation they care for.
Nothing wrong with them, most likely, but certainly not people I'd want to invest emotionally in. YMMV, of course.
By that logic, listing any book as a favorite would mean that you have a limited intellectual horizon, after all, you only care for the intellectual stimulation provided by that book.
The brilliance of the Potter books is more in the way that they start off as being extremely accessible to children, but by the time the series finishes, they are truly adult-level books. It's a good way of getting children through that speed hump - most young children read, but many stop during adolescense. Harry and Co help with this problem.
have you read it?
I've read all of them. They're a lot of fun, but I think it's important to go beyond them and read the books that inspired J.K. Rowling. Joseph Campbell's works on legends and mythology are particularly instructive.