News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by rgbrenner on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @03:16AM (#14955253)
what are you talking about? there's no tax in the paris accord.

Do you mean the fund to help countries affected by climate change? that countries can voluntarily donate money to. They can put anything they want into it, even $0. Those pledges aren't even enforced. A country can pledge whatever, and change their mind later.

You've literally made up several things: a tax; hundreds of billions of dollars; an unaccountable global entity... none of it in the paris accord. I assume that's why you're being accused of being anti-science (if that was really a mystery to you).

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by narrator on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @08:40AM (#14957159)
Here are some sources:

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2017/jun/5/paris-climate...

"Some analysts say the final figure for worldwide compliance with the Paris pledges would be in the trillions of dollars. U.N. officials estimated that it would cost at least $100 billion per year, and that figure could rise to more than $400 billion per year by 2020 to ensure compliance"

Are we going to sign a treaty and spend $0 to comply with it? Is this all supposed to be symbolic? China and Japan and other major economies had not pledged any money toward the treaty while Obama had committed to 3 billion according to the article.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Climate_Fund

This is the supranational entity with a board that gets to disburse the fund. It's like the EU commission all over again.

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by rgbrenner on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @11:43AM (#14958993)
Wait, didnt you write this above: "Let's fund solar power and electric cars and ways to use energy more efficiently, great."

What do you think that is? That's a compliance cost.

You seem to be saying on one hand, "I object to paris accord, lets spend money on climate change ourselves" and then saying "I object to all spending on climate change"

Paris does not force anyone to spend anything or do anything. The goals are all decided by the country itself. The methods used to obtain those goals are also decided by the country itself.

And I'll say again, the Green Climate Fund is completely voluntary. If you dont like it, dont donate to it. And if you don't donate to it, then what is the objection? That other countries might donate to it?

If you're objecting to all spending on climate change, and to a voluntary fund... why not just be straight and say you don't believe in climate change? That would save everyone a lot of time.

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by narrator on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @02:00PM (#14960612)
That the U.S is the only one who donates meaningfully to it and it is basically a slush fund for corruption outside of U.S political control. Why can't the U.S just give grants on a case by case basis to other countries? That money is going to just get squandered and feed corruption if it goes to a U.N body and it won't help the environment. We do get to buy indulgences from the U.N for our overconsumption sins so at least we'll feel better while the climate outcome is the same!

Ideally I'd like to see some foreign aid given out to fund solar energy and wind projects in developing countries with maybe a joint partnership with a U.S operator getting to run the thing so it contributes to our economic development as well. This would actually be a pretty good plan. We could even do it as a loan paid back over a very long period of time by the electricity fees generated so it would generate a positive trade balance over time. Maybe we could build hyperloops and such in developing countries first where there is a drastically lower cost of construction in a joint venture before trying to build them here?

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by rgbrenner on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @03:38PM (#14961686)
First, no one contributes significantly to the climate fund (and it probably wont be until theres significant damage from climate change). The goal was $100b.. the US has pledged $3b, and EU countries have pledged $4.7B.

2nd, it is not outside of US political control. Countries do not pay all of their pledges into the fund. They make payments, basically as needed. The projects that are funded are public. If the US does not like the projects, the President can just refuse to contribute anything else to the fund. I imagine, the US could just earmark funds too (what are they going to do? refuse money? doubt it.) If that's not good enough, the US can always just contribute nothing.

Paris was signed by so many countries because it is completely symbolic. There's no enforcement of anything, and any pledge or goal is entirely up to the country.

Your plan sounds like a good idea.. put an estimate of the amount of carbon that reduces... and you've just created a goal to reduce carbon (just like in Paris!).

In Paris, what happens if your idea turns out to be ineffective? Nothing. What happens if you change your mind? Nothing. What happens if you want to do it differently? Nothing.

That's literally what a carbon goal in Paris is... a vague non-specific plan with a carbon estimate.. that you can change later.

Because Paris forces nothing on to anyone.. the question it really answers is, do politicians/reps of the countries believe in climate change?

Trump has said he believes it's a fraud, completely made up. That's why he withdrew. He has fired climate change scientists, and demanded agencies no longer research the climate, and has removed funds from those agencies for climate change. He has left the heads of scientific agencies completely vacant (no nominations). He doesn't have a plan to accomplish it some other way -- he plans to do nothing. If there was a plan, he could just make that our new paris goal.

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by kristopolous on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @10:29AM (#14958064)
The cost of say, moving Miami and New Orleans would more expensive (ok well, impossible), or reversing the global food chain collapse, or de-acidifying the oceans, these are all currently either impossible or we would need to find some inadequate non-solution in the future costing far more. These problems will only get worse. If they were addressed in the 70s when they were first known about, it'd have been much easier.

Yes, halting the destruction of the planet's ecosystem will cost some money darlin'. And it will always be more tomorrow.

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by JSONwebtoken on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @03:44AM (#14955442)
> They can put anything they want into it, even $0. Those pledges aren't even enforced. A country can pledge whatever, and change their mind later.

Sounds like unlimited vacation. If anybody is trying to sell you something that's "free," you're probably getting a bad deal.

Especially if the only reason it's free for other participants is because they don't expect it to be free for you.

I didn't even say anything about global warming, only the fallibility of such an open-ended agreement structure. I wonder why I'll get down-voted hmm...

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by nl on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @05:55AM (#14956135)
I think you are getting down voted because you seem to have replied to the wrong comment? What you are saying seems irrelevant to the points made.
Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by thinkfurther on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @03:08AM (#14955212)
So you're turning being held accountable into somehow furthering lack of accountability. Not that I think the agreement is super perfect, but that still sticks out like a sore thumb.

> Let's fund solar power and electric cars

You've always been free to do that. You still are. Instead of, say, waging a war of aggression for control of oil, littering the world with military bases, all the while complaining about the specter of a "world government" -- which is anything but the US desires of hegemony, right? No problem with the main superpower being a brute instead of a boon, but a huge problem with the means to defend ourselves. Also see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2C-zWrhFqpM&t=49m38s , and for now in general I'll just say "no". Not good enough. Too little, too late.

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by narrator on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @02:56PM (#14961262)
It's weird how some people seem to think the only two alternatives are neo-con world empire or give all our money to some other guys who aren't accountable to the U.S taxpayer or hardly anyone at all. Can't the American government do pro-climate things itself instead of paying money to someone else whose only qualification is that they don't have any reputation yet for corruption because they haven't done anything yet?
Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by thinkfurther on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @05:47PM (#14963159)
I actually agree, I would prefer more voluntary action, too. But what's keeping the US from doing these things, other than "the" US itself?
Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by pimmen on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @04:33AM (#14955749)
First, the Paris accords does not create a body which enforces it. Second, there is no tax, there's however a fund to help countries affected very severely by climate change, feel free to donate how much you want.

And third, we in the rest of the world have had it with America's vague promises to better themselves, which they promptly call into question by building more pipelines and start exploiting oil shales. You've exhausted your trust in this matter, if we're going to trust you, put it in writing this time. But your administration decided just doing that was too much, that's why we're mighty pissed outside of the US.

Re:Government Report Finds Drastic Impact of Climate Change ... by lumberjack on Tuesday August 08, 2017 @04:04AM (#14955548)
You cannot halt global emissions by installing solar panels in Nevada.

You cannot expect developing countries to halt their carbon emissions without some king of financial help to balance out the costs incurred.