Re:In Earth's hottest place, life has been found in strong acid
by Pulcinella on Monday August 07, 2017 @08:34PM
(#14952479)
[H+] is shorthand for [H3O+]. H3O+ (hydronium ion) requires water plus a hydrogen ion from the acid. There aren't actually free H+ ions floating around. They are all attached to water molecules.
Re:In Earth's hottest place, life has been found in strong acid
by yogipatel on Monday August 07, 2017 @09:08PM
(#14952663)
That's the definition of p[H]. The definition of the "real" pH is the -log of H+ activity. H+ activity is the concentration of H+ * a coefficient. In practice, the coefficient is considered to be 1, however there are cases (such as extreme concentrations) when that approximation isn't valid.
Re:In Earth's hottest place, life has been found in strong acid
by Pulcinella on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:03PM
(#14953056)
Ah yes I had forgotten about activity. :)
Edit regarding your reply asserting water is necessary (I can't reply now due to throttling):
What about all the acid/base reactions that don't involve water? You can't ascribe any pH to either of them in that case?