Re:Web Assembly Working Group Charter Approved
by wahern on Monday August 07, 2017 @10:46PM
(#14953485)
Apparently not. From "ARM Architecture Reference Manual ARMv8 for ARMv8-A architecture profile",
Apart from Load-Exclusive, Store-Exclusive, Load-Acquire,
and Store-Release, addresses can have any alignment unless
strict alignment checking is enabled....
-- Section C3.2 Loads and Stores, page C3-160.
The Load-Exclusive/Store-Exclusive instructions other than
Load-Exclusive pair and Store-Exclusive pair require natural
alignment, and an unaligned address generates an Alignment
fault. Memory accesses generated by Load-Exclusive pair or
Store-Exclusive pair instructions must be aligned to the
size of the pair, otherwise the access generates an
Alignment fault.
-- Section C3.2.6 Load-Exclusive/Store-Exclusive
The Load-Acquire/Store-Release instructions other than Load
Acquire pair and Store-Release pair require natural
alignment, and an unaligned address generates an Alignment
fault. Memory accesses generated by Load-Acquire pair or
Store-Release pair instructions must be aligned to the size
of the pair, otherwise the access generates an Alignment
fault.
-- Section C3.2.7 Load-Acquire/Store-Release
The LoadLOAcquire/StoreLORelease instructions require
natural alignment, and an unaligned address generates an
Alignment fault.
-- Source C3.2.8 LoadLOAcquire/StoreLORelease
The CAS and CASP instructions require natural alignment, and
an unaligned address generates an Alignment fault.
-- Section 3.2.12 Compare and Swap, page C3-172
The LD<OP> and ST<OP> instructions require natural
alignment, and an unaligned address generates an Alignment
fault.
-- Section C3.2.13 Atomic memory operations, page C3-173.
The SWP instructions require natural alignment, and an
unaligned address generates an Alignment fault.
-- Section C3.2.14 Swap, page C3-175
I've only ever dabbled in assembly programming, but the ability of x86 to do atomic operations across cache lines is, AFAIU, rather unique. That Intel and AMD engineers are able to accomplish it relatively performantly is an incredible achievement. But it's not a handicap anybody else wishes to adopt and then compensate for.
Re:Web Assembly Working Group Charter Approved
by ThisIs_MyName on Saturday August 05, 2017 @10:32AM
(#14935900)
Ok so they have hardware support for unaligned accesses, but is it atomic?
On x86 a 64 bit atomic can span cache lines.
> Are you really sure ARM and POWER support that?
Do they not?
http://infocenter.arm.com/help/index.jsp?topic=/com.arm.doc....
On older processors, such as ARM9 family based processors, an unaligned load had to be synthesised in software. Typically by doing a series of small accesses, and combining the results.
"The ARMv6 architecture introduced the first hardware support for unaligned accesses. ARM11 and Cortex-A/R processors can deal with unaligned accesses in hardware, removing the need for software routines."