Re:Vermont Medical School Says Goodbye to Lectures
by timthorn on Saturday August 05, 2017 @06:13AM
(#14935045)
Cambridge and oxford use a mix of lectures and supervision/tutorials - it's not a new thing: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tutorial_system
Most disciplines have never needed lots of theoretical preparation before someone could be put to work, so lectures weren't even necessary. The master could just show the apprentice how his apprentice how he does something, and then let him practice for a few hours.
The more theoretical fields probably started with small groups of wealthy people, which allowed much more direct interaction with the teacher. And what I have read from ancient Greek philosophers almost always involves some kind of dialogue between teacher and students. I can't really imagine aristocrats quietly listening to a lecturer anyway.
The first lectures to a large audience in an amphitheater were probably public dissections, and even there the medical students had plenty of opportunity to do the cutting themselves, under the direction of the lecturer.
The current "traditional" style of non-interactive lectures is probably actually very recent; together with the emergence of mass-education.
Your "active reading" sounds very much like the descriptions I have read of writing circles in creative writing, where students read each other's work and discuss how to improve it. It seems to work fairly well for them. Of course everyone still reads other books, but that they can do alone, while "active reading" can only be done together.
What this means for active learning is that when classroom presence is used for interaction with other students and the teacher, while students who need lectures watch them on their own, this is no indication of failure, but the system working as intended. (Except having to pay for lecture videos. Those should be free.)
The whole point of being in the same room is the possibility of interaction. If the lecturer is just going to rattle off their script while flipping through the slides, I would rather watch that on video where I can set 2x speed until the hard part starts.