News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vermont Medical School Says Goodbye to Lectures by maxxxxx on Friday August 04, 2017 @03:01PM (#14931067)
I am glad I didn't have to study that way. I am notoriously bad at "collaborative learning" in team settings. I probably wouldn't have learned anything in school.
Re:Vermont Medical School Says Goodbye to Lectures by SkyMarshal on Friday August 04, 2017 @03:10PM (#14931151)
Agreed, learning teamwork and team problem solving is useful, but only after individual mastery of the skills in question first. There's no way to shortcut mastery, it takes individual effort, practice, and time. Do that first, then teamwork later with a group of similarly skilled people.

Also, different people have different individual learning styles (aural, visual, doing) and learning paces, so when you mix a bunch of folks with those differences, before all of them have mastered the material, some are going to get left behind and others held back. Ideally learning environments and methodologies account for and adjust for that.

To be fair, Vermont Med School's methodology in the article does appear to account for this, requiring some degree of individual mastery before group work:

>A lot of the science of pharmacokinetics is simply mathematical equations. If you have a lecture, it's simply presenting those equations and maybe giving examples of how they work.

>In an active learning setting, you expect the students to learn about the equations before they get there. And when you get into the classroom setting, the students work in groups solving pharmacokinetic problems. Cases are presented where the patient gets a drug in a certain dose at a certain time, and you're looking at the action of that over time and the concentration of the drug in the blood.

>So, those are the types of things where you're expecting the student to know the knowledge in order to use the knowledge. And then they don't forget it.

Re:Vermont Medical School Says Goodbye to Lectures by tdb7893 on Friday August 04, 2017 @05:44PM (#14932572)
That's really interesting to me because I'm the opposite. I skipped many of my lectures in college and learned through the book or working with my peers. I didn't feel like going to lectures added much to my learning but they added a ton to burnout. Everyone is a little different I guess.
Re:Vermont Medical School Says Goodbye to Lectures by watwut on Friday August 04, 2017 @03:22PM (#14931255)
Collaborative learning means less individual problem solving. The moment there is someone a bit faster then you in the group, the less occasion to think you have.
Re:Vermont Medical School Says Goodbye to Lectures by maxxxxx on Friday August 04, 2017 @04:15PM (#14931834)
It's not even about someone being faster but just different. That together with some people being dominant I would probably contribute nothing to the group because my approach is often different.