News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by EADGBE on Friday August 04, 2017 @09:37AM (#14928532)
"Simple: don’t show any profits" is a concept that's been used forever to avoid paying taxes from the local handyman all the way to Amazon.

It isn't evil, but just try and convince some people that.

Especially that handyman, who's trying to avoid those estimated payments in a slow business part of the year.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by supergeek133 on Friday August 04, 2017 @09:42AM (#14928556)
Exactly, anyone that wants proof of this just needs to do business with a tradeperson outside of the big cities.

Family has had a cabin home about an hour outside of Minneapolis, whenever I need something (plumbing, woodwork, etc) I always ask for the cash price. You can get huge discounts because the business simply doesn't have to report it (they DO but no way to track it).

I personally don't think it should be frowned upon.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by lawnchair_larry on Friday August 04, 2017 @09:52AM (#14928625)
You don't think felony tax evasion should be frowned upon? That goes far beyond tax avoidance.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by supergeek133 on Friday August 04, 2017 @10:52AM (#14929081)
Do you think it's OK for Amazon and other companies to do this in a more "corporate" sense?

Why is it OK for the big guy but not the little guy just because they have good legal/financial resources? For some small businesses in this country, it's the only way to stay competitive to big enterprise. See: Little pizza shop versus large franchise.

I'm talking about the spirit of the whole thing, not the law.

To be completely honest, most business will tell you this revolves around the criminal amount the card processors take from them in processing fees.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by turc1656 on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:33AM (#14929440)
"I'm talking about the spirit of the whole thing, not the law."

Well, that's the problem. You asked a question about why one is acceptable and another is not and the reason is legality.

What it sounds like is that you want tax reform or to do away with loopholes, which is fine. There's a lot of shady/questionable/unethical things that the law allows and corporations take advantage of them whenever they can. And let's be serious - you would, too, if you had the resources become a multinational conglomerate and have the best accountants and tax attorneys that money could buy. We all would, especially if we were CEO/CFO of one of these firms with a responsibility to look out for shareholders. If you can deliver more money to them and you don't, you're probably going to be out on your ass real fast. The solution is to change the law because you are never going to convince people to not use it to their advantage. If I had a company and people told me I could make an extra 200k a year just by restructuring the company and making a few adjustments that would be frowned upon by society but would not land me in jail, the odds of me not doing it are slim to none.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by supergeek133 on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:47AM (#14929556)
Yes, again, I'm talking the spirit vs the letter of the law.

Of course everyone who learns the can "legally" circumvent the law, will. That's clear with every large company in the US.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by semafour on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:02AM (#14929175)
Credit card rates with your own merchant account are 3% - 8%, depending on your industry and chargeback history.

Federal Marginal tax rates are 10% - 38%, plus maybe 5% in MN.

If they are giving you a 5% - 10% discount for cash, sure, it's probably because they appreciate skipping the credit card. If they give you a larger discount for paying in cash, they probably aren't reporting the income.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by EADGBE on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:23AM (#14929361)
CC rates can be negotiated down below 3%.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by semafour on Friday August 04, 2017 @01:03PM (#14930088)
For card-present goods and services it's likely lower, but for card-not-present online software sales from a small company, rates with your own merchant account can be even higher than 8%. This is a big advantage of using Stripe and the like.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by supergeek133 on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:43AM (#14929510)
Depends on the business.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by supergeek133 on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:44AM (#14929529)
Yes that's for sure, I'm just stating all the causes of the proliferation of this problem.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by lawnchair_larry on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:32AM (#14929432)
The question of whether or not the rules are equitable is complicated.

The problem with your position is that it reduces us to "nobody should have to pay taxes, ever". That's most definitely not going to work.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by supergeek133 on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:45AM (#14929539)
That's not true, in my opinion it goes back to the equity conversation. Per another comment what Amazon and the little guy are doing are different in process/principle, however the resulting impact to the government is orders of magnitude larger from Amazon, no?

I guess there is no way to estimate the total $ missing from small business to compare.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by z2600 on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:18AM (#14929321)
It also means that sales tax is being avoided with a cash transaction. Although, I guess Amazon also avoids the sales tax...
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by turc1656 on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:58AM (#14929639)
No, they don't avoid it. I pay sales tax on every purchase I make on Amazon. It is required based on the laws of certain states. I recall there being some law passed a while ago regarding this.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by tome on Friday August 04, 2017 @10:58AM (#14929149)
What Amazon does is completely different!
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by supergeek133 on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:44AM (#14929521)
The laws by which they retain their cash are different yes, but is the result? Not to mention the order of magnitude is larger.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by tome on Friday August 04, 2017 @03:13PM (#14931176)
Yes, because the money is going directly back into things that benefit the company and returns cashflow which will (presumably) be taxed at a later date.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by candiodari on Friday August 04, 2017 @09:58AM (#14928677)
If you think this behavior is bad in the US, come have a look in Europe. You'll be amazed. And I'm from Northwest Europe, I 'm told I would not believe what common practice is in Greece.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by tclancy on Friday August 04, 2017 @10:39AM (#14928964)
If you ignore scale, sure. A handyman pocketing $100 in cash here and there is a good deal different from a company whose whims could affect the trajectory of the economy.
Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by conanbatt on Friday August 04, 2017 @10:54AM (#14929103)
It's not the act that is evil, is the person doing it, am i rite. We must take the veil off Lady Justice.

Please. Corporate taxes make no sense as they are, companies don't pay taxes, people pay taxes. And corporate taxes more often than not fall on the consumer.

Re:Increasingly, businesses don’t generate profits – they ge... by EADGBE on Friday August 04, 2017 @10:47AM (#14929034)
I wasn't insinuating pocketing cash.

I was insinuating tax avoidance methods. Which are completely legal and how every small business stays afloat. (Write offs, SEP IRA, Depreciation, company car, office space, etc.)