If you're an above-average HN reader who knows something about security, then absolutely you should hold your own coins.
But for the average person the chances are much higher that they will get hacked or lose their keys than losing their coins on Coinbase.
> The whole point of Bitcoin is that you are your own bank
There are several important differences between Bitcoin and traditional currencies. This may be the most important one to you, but it is not to everyone.
Given the high profile attacks on crypto exchanges over recent years, how much trust do you place in Gemini securing your SSN, proof of ID, and proof of address?
Not very much, but only because those are byproducts of a cryptocurrency hack. If they didn't control centralized private keys and thus implicitly have one of the biggest bug bounties, I would be less worried about people hacking my SSN, ID, etc. from Gemini.
That said, I also don't care as much if those get hacked as I can recover from stolen identity, while it's impossible to get back stolen bitcoin.
Re:Update on Bitcoin Cash
by finnjohnsen2 on Friday August 04, 2017 @06:31AM
(#14927636)
They are so convenient though :)
Don't let centralized authorities keep your private keys.