Re:Canadian cable companies interrogate, search Montréal sof...
by jostmey on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @12:39PM
(#14912098)
If the defendant is known to possess incriminating evidence then you already have all the proof you need. The law is an oxymoron and dangerous.
Re:Canadian cable companies interrogate, search Montréal sof...
by pavel_lishin on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @01:17PM
(#14912567)
> If the defendant is known to possess incriminating evidence then you already have all the proof you need.
Knowing that someone has evidence isn't the same thing as having that evidence.
Its intended use seems to be for cases where the defendant is known to possess incriminating material they are in imminent danger of destroying, and have caused serious damage to the plaintiff. It also seems that an independent lawyer is required in these cases to explain the order to the defendant and handle the collected material.
The judge apparently ruled the use of the order unlawful after the fact, so I'd hope that the poor guy is entitled to some sort of compensation.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anton_Piller_order#Canada