Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by dogecoinbase on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @04:33PM
(#14905037)
Bitcoin as money has all the worst properties of both credit cards (traceable, non-anonymous) and cash (irreversible, theft-prone).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by darawk on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @05:12PM
(#14905390)
It isn't intrinsically theft prone, the UI around using it is just not up to snuff yet. Credit cards, on the other hand, are intrinsically theft prone. They are a pull architecture. Every time you use your credit card, the store takes money from you. This is patently absurd, and the only reasonable definition of 'theft prone'. Bitcoin is a push architecture. You can never take my bitcoin, I can only send you bitcoin. Further, irreversibility is definitely what you want in the underlying protocol. It's fine if people want to implement escrowing and chargebacks via intermediaries on top of Bitcoin, and I would encourage that. But at a fundamental level, a payment system should be irreversible, immutable, uncensorable and push-based. Which is exactly what Bitcoin is.
Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by empthought on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @01:26AM
(#14908145)
> Every time you use your credit card, the store takes money from you.
No, precisely no credit cards work that way. That's why they're called credit cards.
Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by darawk on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @03:59AM
(#14908736)
The money is taken from the credit card company, then. The architecture is still pull. You're splitting hairs.
Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by empthought on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @08:03PM
(#14915837)
That's not splitting hairs; that's literally the point of credit cards. It is entirely "push" from my perspective, modulo the minimum monthly payment and tolerance for paying interest and bad credit.
If I buy something with a credit card for $2k and have $2k in my bank account, the $2k is still there until I pay the credit card company. It could take years or be paid off immediately.
It's not a "pull" at all.
Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by darawk on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @09:06PM
(#14916147)
It is a pull. You bear the costs of fraud whether you notice them or not. The fact that the credit card company hides those costs from you doesn't change the fact that their architecture is broken, and that you are still paying for it by virtue of the fees they charge merchants, which create higher sticker prices for you. Costs like that don't simply disappear into the ether - you, the consumer, pays them.
Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by vageli on Thursday August 03, 2017 @01:35PM
(#14921732)
Every consumer who doesn't use credit cards also bears the fees since it is rare to find a merchant that offers a "cash discount".
Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by darawk on Thursday August 03, 2017 @04:12PM
(#14923357)
Ya, also true, and good point.
Re:Why aren’t distributed systems engineers working on block...
by empthought on Thursday August 03, 2017 @06:23AM
(#14918349)
Precisely none of that is "Every time you use your credit card, the store takes money from you."