Employees take shortcuts around bureaucracy all the time. Sometimes (often?) that bureaucracy is for legal reasons.
Your argument is the correct moral and legal one. Unfortunately that doesn't always matter. For another example, see the cognitive dissonance many express regarding ad blocking (not to come down entirely on one side of that issue, it's complicated).
If your company gets aquired one day, the code will probably be audited during the due diligence process. If licence violations related to copy-pasting is found, your team will be asked to remove the infringing code and your supervisor may be fired. This happened to my team in the first company I worked for (not the firing part though) : we had a lot of code which was just copy-pasted from lodash and the audit found it.