News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by bpodgursky on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @11:36AM (#14901819)
Because some of us care about the environment more than we like populist posturing.
Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by epistasis on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @12:39PM (#14902596)
While it may be important to correct the record on the safety of nuclear, if one really cares about the environment, one shouldn't be attached to just one solution like nuclear.

In a political environment where approximately half of the country has been tricked by propaganda to disbelieve the basics of climate science, we can't get attached to expensive solutions like nuclear that require lots of public financial and political support. We need the carbon-free electricity to be the cheapest option, as dollars are probably the only thing that can overcome the anti-climate-change political ideology.

Market solutions are the best option now, and though well-sited solar and wind are the cheapest source of power at the moment, they need to be distributed properly both in time and in geography. Storage and HVDC are the solutions that make this possible. Storage is getting super cheap, and is on the cusp of becoming a universal install with all new renewables. HVDC is getting somewhat cheaper, and other countries are building tons of it. Getting HVDC built does require some political support, because it means getting different grids to interact with each other.

We need to be realistic about nuclear. Refusing to hold people accountable for bad decisions on nuclear isn't fighting against populist posturing, it's just protecting poor decision makers and preventing better ones from taking their place. These utilities have had poor decision makers that have been unfairly biased against renewable energy over the past decade, and are only ever so slowly awakening to the financial realities out there. South Carolina needs utility execs that are forward thinking, understand technology and how its changing, and are not stuck in the 80s or 90s. Only then will they be proper stewards of South Carolin's finances and environment.

Imagine if South Carolina had been building off shore wind, at $9B. They amount of industry that would have been gained off that would have been immense. South Carolina companies would have had the knowledge to build off-shore wind all over the East Coast. And it would be local corporations, not foreign contractors like Dong energy.

We need to get out of the past, and look to the future of technology. Nuclear had its day, and may again in the future, but for the coming decades it is not a terribly great option, at more than say 1%-5% of our energy supply.

Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by 6d6b73 on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:21PM (#14903063)
When you show me how to safely store radioactive waste for the thousands of years that are required to make it safe, I consider nuclear power as a safe, effective and economically viable option.

If you care about the environment, tell me what would happen to all of the nuclear plants and the nuclear waste, if suddenly all or most of the people on this planet died?

Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by opo on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @12:48AM (#14907995)
>...When you show me how to safely store radioactive waste for the thousands of years that are required to make it safe, I consider nuclear power as a safe, effective and economically viable option.

Right now nuclear waste can and should be recycled which would reduce the amount of waste: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioactive_waste

Soon it will be possible to use most of the waste as fuel:

"...Fast reactors can "burn" long lasting nuclear transuranic waste (TRU) waste components (actinides: reactor-grade plutonium and minor actinides), turning liabilities into assets. Another major waste component, fission products (FP), would stabilize at a lower level of radioactivity than the original natural uranium ore it was attained from in two to four centuries, rather than tens of thousands of years"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integral_fast_reactor

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_IV_reactor

While there are issues with nuclear power, the worry people have about nuclear waste is greatly overblown to say the least. The amounts generated are manageable and in a relatively short amount of time we can use most of this "waste" to generate electricity.

Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by 6d6b73 on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @07:21AM (#14909629)
> Right now nuclear waste can and should be recycled which would reduce the amount of waste

But it's not, and even when it was it would just reduce the amount not get rid of. Also it would make the whole nuclear energy economically unfeasible.

".Fast reactors can "burn" long lasting nuclear transuranic waste (TRU) waste components"

From your linked article: "At present there are no Integral Fast Reactors in commercial operation".

"While there are issues with nuclear power, the worry people have about nuclear waste is greatly overblown to say the least"

If it's overblown why it's not a solved problem already? Nuclear power currently is not safe, waste storage is a problem, and it's not by any means economical.

Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by opo on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @02:25PM (#14913239)
>But it's not,

Reprocessing is done in various countries around the world though right now it is cheaper to refine new ore.

>...Also it would make the whole nuclear energy economically unfeasible.

The fuel cost is a small part of the cost so I am not sure why you think it would be "economically unfeasible". Over time it will likely become cheaper and as we continue to use uranium, that price will likely rise so the economics will likely shift.

>...From your linked article: "At present there are no Integral Fast Reactors in commercial operation".

Sigh. I was hoping that you were actually interested in having a dialogue and understanding the current state of things and where they will be in a few decades. When you ignore what I write and cherry pick responses, it looks more like you have a deeply held belief and it really doesn't matter what anyone says to you. What I wrote was "Soon it will be possible to use most of the waste as fuel:" - I did not say a 4th gen reactor that could burn waste was running right now. Most of the designs being worked on are generally not expected to be available for construction until the 2020s. Do you have any evidence that we can't store nuclear waste on site until a 4th gen reactor would be available?

>...Nuclear power currently is not safe, waste storage is a problem, and it's not by any means economical.

NOTHING is "safe" the way you define it. Walking across carries some risk, flying in a plane carries risk. The only thing you can do is to compare something it against its alternatives - flying a plane to go across the country is definitely safer than driving. When making a choice you need to worry about relative risk - rather than stay away from airplanes because they aren't "safe". Waste storage from any industrial process is a "problem" - the difference between nuclear and coal is that the industry and its regulators take the waste issue seriously and make sure no one is hurt by it. "and it's not by any means economical." - citation needed. France gets a majority of their power through nuclear power and has lower rates for electricity than its neighbors:

>...France enjoys one of the lowest electricity prices in Europe; at 14.72 euro cents per kWh, the average cost of electricity in France is 26.5% cheaper than the EU average (20.02 euro cents per kWh).

https://en.selectra.info/energy-france/guides/electricity-co...

(France also reprocesses nuclear waste.)

Your original comment was "When you show me how to safely store radioactive waste for the thousands of years that are required to make it safe, I consider nuclear power as a safe effective and economically viable option."

I have given you evidence that your original premise is false - we won't need to store high level wastes for "thousands of years". As I said, while there are issues with nuclear power, the worry people have about nuclear waste is greatly overblown to say the least. Hundreds of thousands of people have died from hydroelectric accidents, literally millions have died from burning fossil fuels, etc - in comparison I've never read of anyone who died from nuclear waste.

Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by bpodgursky on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:29PM (#14903162)
Er... they would turn off?

The 1 lizard in 10,000 years that accidentally wandered into Yucca mountain might die?

I guess losing millions of acres of land and ecosystems to global warming is nothing, as long as we save that lizard.

Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by 6d6b73 on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @01:46PM (#14903350)
Of, they will simply shut down. Right, and they not going to disintegrate within just a few decades.

Even Chernobyl’s New Safe Confinement is designed to last only 100 years. With almost 500 reactors in the world, with 100 years of our disappearance at least some of them would go into meltdown, and destroy most of the life on the planet.. Nuclear indeed is a very environmental option.

Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by bpodgursky on Tuesday August 01, 2017 @02:16PM (#14903666)
You need to do some research. I'm willing to debate points, but nonsense claims like "destroy most of the life on the planet" tell me you are an idealogue with no concept of the orders of magnitude involved in any failure scenario.
Re:U.S. Nuclear Comeback Stalls as Two Reactors Are Abandoned by 6d6b73 on Wednesday August 02, 2017 @08:13AM (#14909852)
Chernobyl and Fukushima were mostly contained by people that were around, yet they still had a profound effect on the environment. Doesn't it make sense that uncontrolled meltdowns at ~ 700 reactors world wide would release so much radiation that pretty much all higher forms of life would die off?