News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Godblock: block violent, sexual, and psychologically harm... by brainproxy on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:21PM (#1489522)
And on a related note: the most violent and death-dealing ideology in the history of the human race is atheistic communism. For the advancement of its "revolution/s" the cost was untold tens of millions of lives throughout the 20th Century, more than all the wars of religion ever fought, all piled together, with even the most liberal estimates.

Just saying ... man seems to do rather poorly on his own when he departs from the love of God, and the love of his neighbor in view of God's love.

Re:Godblock: block violent, sexual, and psychologically harm... by johnfn on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:33PM (#1489544)
It seems like you just strung the word atheist along with the word communism in order to make it seem worse by association. Really, atheism and communism are not inextricably tied: http://atheism.about.com/od/atheismmyths/a/Communism.htm

Blaming atheists for causing communism is sort of like blaming heterosexuals for causing the Holocaust.

Further, it is very difficult to find violence committed in the name of atheism (it seems to be almost a contradiction in terms). Violence committed in the name of God, on the other hand, has been cited in Internet Arguments so often that now it's almost a cliche.

Re:Godblock: block violent, sexual, and psychologically harm... by brainproxy on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:47PM (#1489578)
Communism is one of atheism's terrible and natural fruits, and many of the communist revolutionaries held as a first-rank goal the suppression, if not elimination of, religions and religious institutions.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Book_of_Communism

^^ Go atheism, huzzah!

Seriously, let's learn the lessons from "God blocking", not repeat them.

Re:Godblock: block violent, sexual, and psychologically harm... by anigbrowl on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:37PM (#1489554)
This kind of one-upping (or one-downing, if you prefer) is part of the problem with ideology: deflecting criticism with a tu quoque argument to 'something even worse' means never having to confront one's own failings. The first step away from fanatical authoritarianism (regardless of which ideology it is clothed in) is to reject such zero-sum fallacies.

Incidentally, I also think this argument is flawed on the merits. Apart from the lack of meaningful criteria for establishing which Bad Things can be ascribed to religious or atheistic fanatics, it also sidesteps the legitimate question of what Good Things can be ascribed to religious or humanist progress through time - a general problem in politics of course, because people treating each other decently doesn't make headlines.

Re:Godblock: block violent, sexual, and psychologically harm... by gdl on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:33PM (#1489542)
The world has been much, much more populated now than in the past, and we have much bigger weapons.

There have been very many religiously motivated wars through the ages. Do you think that, had those wars taken place in a world with similar population and weapons technology as today, they would have been any less destructive than our own?

Or is your argument that everyone, including those who love God, try to kill people, and that the atheists are simply better at it due to technology?

Re:Godblock: block violent, sexual, and psychologically harm... by brainproxy on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:51PM (#1489587)
I'm saying a motivated atheist communist has (in his own mind at least) no God before whom he'll stand in judgment for his blunders, failures, excesses, crimes and stupidity.
Re:Godblock: block violent, sexual, and psychologically harm... by gdl on Monday July 05, 2010 @08:55PM (#1489601)
Okay, so then your argument is that atheists don't believe in God. I completely agree with you.