Sorry, our post just reminded me of the scene :)
Just then they heard the children calling, "Daddy, Mommy, come quick -quick!"
They went downstairs in the air flue and ran down the hall. The children were nowhere in sight. "Wendy? Peter!"
They ran into the nursery. The veldtland was empty save for the lions waiting, looking at them. "Peter, Wendy?"
The door slammed.
- Ray Bradbury, The Veldt[0]
There was a lot of questions growing up about particular hobbies for example, that I would just find online as no one in my small town would have any similar interests.
Same deal for homework eg; Algebra that my parents weren't able to answer, as neither had finished high school themselves nor having gone on to take STEM-ish careers.
Learning how to properly search is pretty much one of the most valuable skills you can have!
I think talking to Alexa is wonky on the surface, sure, but it's just changing the way in which you access the same information.
That said, there's a huge difference between getting your first computer at 12 and getting your first computer at 3 (or at least largely unmonitored access to one). It remains to be seen how interaction with technology at such a young age affects social development and maturity, whereas technology's impact on our lives occurred after that development had mostly finished.
It started with, "surely, if the computer can beat a human in chess, that must mean it's intelligent". Then went from there.
This was done to avoid heresy, insurrection and rebellion, but it has wider implications.
Computers are just another tool in this change. In fact, computers could even help parents to regain a bit of the privilege to provide education to their children.
Or let Bezos dictate which views your child acquires.
But if it helps to ease your cynical concerns, you can donate money to Wikipedia.
There's more to parenting than on-demand answers to questions, and obedient execution of verbal commands.
>>I couldn't help but think it won't be too long until kids don't need parents much
I think you meant need as pure "question answerers," but we do a few things for the kids that Siri and Alexa wouldn't have the stomach or, for that matter, the arms for. Oh, also: love!
Eg:
Instead of:
- Why does it rain ?
- Well, you see, there's that thing about clouds that goes through different pocket of air and...
Try:
- Why does it rain ?
- To make vegetables grow :).
YMMV
There's far more to nurturing children that what we have been able to pinpoint so far (as parents and as scientists).
It takes a village.
Reminds me of the movie, Her
This has almost always been the case. Have you met a single millennial?
After some quick searching, it appears the starting birth year for millenials can be considered to go as far back as 1977. Having personally been born in 1980, I've never characterized myself as what I hear a "millennial" to be, and the people I know in my age range feel the same way about themselves.
I suspect that not wanting to be labeled a millenial is one of the defining characteristics.
I suspect this is true for literally everybody. Which is because these characterizations are reductive nonsense: people contain multitudes.
But, people like their boxes and generalizations, or so it seems.
So to me it does feel like those "new" problems are not so new after all. Technology is just changing the mode of interaction, not the fundamental dynamic that lets kids entertain themselves without their parents.
on the one hand that will be great. a partner who never gets tired no matter how many questions you ask.
on the other hand it's a brave new world. especially when as the computer gets better they might get used to the partner that always does there requests and upset with the real people who dont ?
I'm sure it will all be fine somehow.