News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exactly-once or not, atomic broadcast is still impossible... by closeparen on Saturday July 29, 2017 @08:04PM (#14883653)
Compared to what?

I've often heard wisdom like "it's irresponsible to use Kafka when you could just use RabbitMQ" but why does that statement not work equally well in the opposite direction?

It seems like some "you don't need this fad technology" sentiments don't provide a whole lot of justification for sticking with the unfashionable choice. Does it all come down to "the devil you know?" What if you aren't that experienced with either choice?

Re:Exactly-once or not, atomic broadcast is still impossible... by sidlls on Saturday July 29, 2017 @08:33PM (#14883768)
> I've often heard wisdom like "it's irresponsible to use Kafka when you could just use RabbitMQ" but why does that statement not work equally well in the opposite direction?

It could, in some circumstances. Generally, though, the two have only a very small overlap with respect to messaging use cases. One was designed to be general purpose and solve a variety of MQ use cases and serve even "dumb" clients. One was designed very specifically to impose a high burden of state tracking on clients for a very specific paradigm.

> It seems like some "you don't need this fad technology" sentiments don't provide a whole lot of justification for sticking with the unfashionable choice.

The "unfashionable choice" that works doesn't need justification. The new shiny one does.

Re:Exactly-once or not, atomic broadcast is still impossible... by closeparen on Saturday July 29, 2017 @11:43PM (#14884339)
>The "unfashionable choice" that works doesn't need justification

Why? That's what I'm asking.

Re:Exactly-once or not, atomic broadcast is still impossible... by suchire on Saturday July 29, 2017 @11:59PM (#14884392)
The older choice usually by default has:

- More people who know how to operate it

- A greater portion of its failure modes that are known, with workarounds

- Mature tooling and libraries

New technologies need a compelling reason that their pros will outweigh the above incumbent benefits.