Unlike 'bad', a subjective word indicating opinion, 'incorrect' is objective: anything can be incorrect according to a certain set of parameters, and the author is selecting a particularly traditional set here from the book in order to frame the discussion.
He's not implying that Sonic is bad. He calls it a masterpiece!
It's quite likely he's also a Lorde fan.
With pop songs and games, there are formulae that, if you just follow them correctly, you are basically guaranteed to make something that is at least mediocre. Breaking the rules is more interesting, but also more risky. For every sonic and every Green Light, there are hundreds or thousands of crappy games and songs that thought the rules didn't apply to them.
Analyzing successful "incorrect" games is interesting because it tries to pin-down the je ne sais quoi that gives them their appeal.
If one does not like a game, we have a word for that: "bad". There are plenty of bad games to analyze. Why the author picked Sonic the Hedgehog is beyond me.
As he said: it works. Therefore, to twist the word "incorrect" to its breaking point as he does is ridiculous.