Re:GPL Violations Related to Combining ZFS and Linux (2016)
by protomyth on Thursday July 27, 2017 @05:14PM
(#14869617)
I have read it, but not all of the files are under the "later" clause. Its a small number right now, but it will probably increase. So Oracle cannot do the whole OpenZFS in one swoop.
Re:GPL Violations Related to Combining ZFS and Linux (2016)
by cyphar on Thursday July 27, 2017 @10:33PM
(#14871486)
The majority of OpenZFS hasn't exercised the opt-out (and most importantly, the portions that are from the original ZFS are definitely not exercising the opt-out). There are two possible options:
1. Re-implement those files. 2. Ask the current copyright holder to remove the opt-out.
Given how small the number of lines is[1], I would be surprised if re-implementing would take more than a few weeks.
It's effectively the same mechanism as MPL's update system, and also effectively the same as GPL's update mechanism. You can take a GPLv2-or-later codebase and redistribute it as GPLv3-or-later because the FSF has released GPLv3. Similarly, you can take a CDDL-1.0 codebase and redistribute it as CDDL-2.0 because the "or any later version" clause is implicit and opt-out.
If you agree that GPLv2-or-later code (regardless of who owns the copyright) can be redistributed or combined with GPLv3-or-later code, then you agree with the basic point of what I'm saying. Obviously the specifics are different but the basic idea is the same.
Seriously. Read section 4 of the CDDL[1]. It's only three short paragraphs.
[1]: https://github.com/zfsonlinux/zfs/blob/master/OPENSOLARIS.LI...