And once it's actually synchronized HDD or SSD doesn't matter much in my experience.
I don't think it's really a factor in adoption, most users don't feel the need to run a node already. People running nodes are enthusiasts first and foremost.
That's a big part of the issue. Already people prefer to run lite clients for convenience. There are heavy systemic risks that get worse and worse as the number of full nodes decrease. Back room deals become a lot easier for those who do run full nodes, because there aren't enough people running full nodes to prevent unfavorable network changes.
One you have synced your node, an HDD isn't a big deal but if you only run your node every few weeks or months you have thousands of blocks to sync each time. Then it's a pain, and SSDs are nicer. (This is my personal situation). I typically only boot my node if I intend to spend or receive coins, the sync time is already frustrating to me on an SSD and i7.
You don't want an ecosystem where only enthusiasts are verifying transactions. That's abusable, and if it forms a significant part of the economy it absolutely will be abused.
It's true but as I pointed out in a sibling comment those risks are pretty slim as long as it's highly unlikely that all node runners could be colluding. It takes only one "uncorrupted" node to raise the alarm publicly, then anybody can spawn a node and check for themselves if they want.
>You don't want an ecosystem where only enthusiasts are verifying transactions. That's abusable, and if it forms a significant part of the economy it absolutely will be abused.
Okay but that's the way bitcoin works, with or without SegWit, with or without big blocks. There are not enough incentives to run a full node already. I don't think that will change unless you manage to create an incentive somehow.
For $20 a month someone could easily run a large-block full node and that price will only come down.
Also, would you pay $20/mo for a credit card? That's a big expense to participate in a financial system.
How many independent nodes do we need to ensure it keeps working?
When the lightning network is up and running you can bet that I'll be using my full node for that too.
120GB of disk space is a big hit. My drive is a 500GB SSD. Bitcoin runs a lot slower on an HDD. But mostly people saying "oh it's only $5 a month" I feel aren't actually running nodes. It's inconvenient already, the sizes are already hurting adoption, and making the chain bigger is definitely going to make that situation worse.