How long would it take you to download the initial data? I don't think a 2 channel ISDN link could ever catch up.
But again, you can't compare this to going offchain! You can never catch up with the private networks doing settlement on BTC. But if you just want to validate going forward, then you need 2GB of UTXO data, plus a checkpoint hash and you can validate from there on out.
From a Bitfury paper on the subject [1]:
8MB blocksize requires: 411GB/year extra space, 1184kB/s average bandwidth, 35.4TB/year bandwidth, and 32GB RAM.
If that isn't enough to scale, which it won't be if Bitcoin is to fulfill its goals of being able to compete with the currently leading payment networks, take a look at something like 32MB blocks:
32MB blocksize requires: 1643GB/year extra space, 4736kB/s average bandwidth, 141TB/year bandwidth, and 128GB RAM.
Although these numbers are possible to meet, it's obvious that not everyone is going to have hardware like this just to run a Bitcoin node. So it's predicted that so many nodes will be excluded for larger blocksizes (90%+), that the decentralization will take a huge blow.
[1] http://bitfury.com/content/5-white-papers-research/block-siz..., page 4
The BW calculations are misleading - that counts transmitting the blockchain to other nodes. To validate transactions and participate, you don't need to upload it, only download. Also, if we consider transaction history irrelevant since Lightning or other offchain solutions are OK, then all that is needed is the last few blocks and UTXO.
As Satoshi said, once client-only is in, it doesn't really matter, and the answer is to not care how big it gets. (Sure, quoting him isn't an end-all, but it shows the original design goals.)
Also, none of this explains why an increase to say, 2MB was never done, unless it's a game of chicken.
I guess it was just a matter of time until this happened, though ideally it would've been many years rather than two years.
https://www.engadget.com/2016/10/06/comcasts-1tb-data-caps-s...
It's "only" $50/mo extra to get unlimited, but if you don't have it then it can cost up to +$200/mo.
And for someone that cannot afford a 100$ drive every 5 years, toss the old blocks after saving a checkpoint and just keep the last X months plus UTXOs?
How does this improve with offchain transactions? What's the point of validating the blockchain if it's no longer a peer to peer network? That can't be any better than validating from checkpoints.