Gaddafi was not toppled because he was going to kill civilians. In fact, it is the other way around. Gaddafi has been killing his opposing politicians for decades. This happened with the best knowledge of his US, EU friends at the time and at really a ridiculous and holocaustic level.
The time the US intervened was when he was going to "truly" protect his country or power from real armed extremists.
If you think the US intervene for the sake of "humans" then you are gullible to your media. The US has been actively intervening in the middle east which resulted in countless (hundreds of thousands) of people and children dying directly from US fire.
There are thousands of people dying from hunger every day. The cost to feed them is certainly much less than the cost of wars the US has engaged. But the US will not help these "black" guys despite having the food, infrastructure and money.
The US only intervenes in countries where there are strategic resources; or to help its allies ( israel / south korea ).
I think people are too quick to pass judgment on US or NATO intervention in matters and aren't acknowledging the extreme complexity involved in making the right decision. When dealing with some of these international conflicts, sometimes it's less a matter of making the right choice but rather making the least awful choice, and it's often impossible to determine the true consequences of decisions in advance.
Yes, that is what I think.
So why did the U.S. intervene? Gaddafi was going to ruthlessly slaughter everyone in Benghazi. He said so, and had the tanks to do it rolling across the desert. It turns out that the U.S. military is really good at killing tanks in the desert (esp in a low air defense threat environment), so the White House and DoD knew that they would have blood on their hands if they stood by and watched. Also, unlike Syria, Gaddafi had no strategic allies to complicate things. That is, other than us.
And now we get to suffer the long term consequences of preventing that genocide by stabbing a new friend in the back. We saved lives in Benghazi and toppled a ruthless dictator. We also fueled the rise of ISIS, and helped pave the way for nuclear confrontations in Korea and the Middle East.