Re:Ask HN: How Did You Think About Having Children?
by trevyn on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @07:29PM
(#14861325)
If your ethics include reducing human suffering, deciding to conceive is unethical due to the quantity of pain your child is almost certain to endure.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: How Did You Think About Having Children?
by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @08:24PM
(#14861635)
> If your ethics include reducing human suffering, deciding to conceive is unethical due to the quantity of pain your child is almost certain to endure.
If your ethics are limited to reducing some simplistic measure of suffering, that seems clear.
OTOH, under such an ethical system, if there were a means to immediately and painlessly eradicate humanity, it would be ethically obligatory to execute it.
If, to go to an opposite extreme, your ethics is limited to maximizing human joy, refraining from having a child would, in most situations, be unethical.
Real world ethical systems (both as expressed and the things people actually believe) tend to be more complex, though, than either extreme simplification.
Re:Ask HN: How Did You Think About Having Children?
by sp527 on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @07:59PM
(#14861503)
Interesting viewpoint. I disagree in that I don't believe pain and suffering are the same thing. A lot of philosophy that's been top of mind for me recently suggests we can experience pain without choosing to suffer. Suffering is avoidable but pain is necessary and arguably desirable. However that's a nuanced issue, and you were probably just treating them as semantically equivalent out of convenience/habit.
Re:Ask HN: How Did You Think About Having Children?
by RhysU on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @07:38PM
(#14861377)
This argument neglects that net suffering might be reduced by having children. Humans judge the time-value of suffering weirdly. That's part of why few save enough for retirement.
Re:Ask HN: How Did You Think About Having Children?
by flavio81 on Wednesday July 26, 2017 @08:16PM
(#14861588)
I almost never complain regarding downvotes, but I can't really understand why on a supposedly civilized place like HN, your comment is already displaying grey (downvoted).
Your argument is quite powerful, really.