Re:Mark Zuckerberg: Success like mine only happens with luck
by gnaritas on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @01:43PM
(#14850022)
They're wrong, those problem can be solved simply by paying out the UBI more often in smaller amounts like a paycheck. Means testing leads to expensive bureaucracies and wasted money. UBI is meant to end that, not supplement it.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg: Success like mine only happens with luck
by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:09PM
(#14850305)
Whether they are right or wrong about the need, the fact is that there is a sizable contingent of UBI supporters that do believe certain other programs are necessary. It is not at all the case that UBI is promoted universally, or even overwhelmingly, as a complete replacement for the welfare state, or even a complete replacement for simply the means-tested compobebts of the welfare state.
Re:Mark Zuckerberg: Success like mine only happens with luck
by gnaritas on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @02:31PM
(#14850548)
Of course, because UBI itself isn't an accepted concept yet; once it becomes one, the natural result of rolling it out will be the elimination of all other welfare programs in favor of the UBI. It's a better abstraction, and good abstractions displace bad ones eventually.
Many what might be called “moderate UBI proponents” have argued that certain use-specific universal or means-tested programs will still be needed because of social costs of failure of individuals to allocate funds properly to certain needs. Different sets have been suggested, but usually one or more of healthcare, food, and housing support programs (in roughly declining order of frequency with which I've seen them suggested) are proposed.