Re:Nixon was told: sea level would rise by 10 feet in 31 years
by philwelch on Saturday July 03, 2010 @04:55PM
(#1484439)
During the Cold War, the US Government had two sets of calculations for the effects of nuclear arms (at least according to my dad, who worked for some time studying tactical nuclear weapons in the Marine Corps). The calculations for American losses were a worst case scenario--in other words, they were a generous overestimate of how much death and destruction nuclear weapons could inflict on American targets. The calculations for enemy losses were also a worst case scenario--in this case, a generous underestimate of how much we could kill and destroy by nuking them. The difference between these figures was often tremendous, and yet both figures remain very legitimate planning tools for the business of nuclear warfare.
If Moynihan's figures were intended to serve as a similar worst case scenario for climate change, they were not off by much--the increase in CO2 concentration was off by less than a factor of 2, and the measurements for temperature and sea level were just over an order of magnitude off (reasonable if you take worst-case scenarios for both CO2 concentration and the effects of higher CO2 concentration).
Incidentally, some factors, such as glacial melting, seem to be progressing faster than contemporary global warming estimates have predicted.
If Moynihan's figures were intended to serve as a similar worst case scenario for climate change, they were not off by much--the increase in CO2 concentration was off by less than a factor of 2, and the measurements for temperature and sea level were just over an order of magnitude off (reasonable if you take worst-case scenarios for both CO2 concentration and the effects of higher CO2 concentration).
Incidentally, some factors, such as glacial melting, seem to be progressing faster than contemporary global warming estimates have predicted.