I think they should.
Why shouldn't there be nice, exclusive areas to live in, just like there are exclusive schools to attend and exclusive companies to work for?
And it creates an urban form that induces long, high-emission solo driver commutes and fewer residents in a part of the country that requires very little HVAC— both of which lead to a lot of climate change.
And it maintains a segregated society, racially and otherwise, where the wealthy may ignore social problems.
And it's likely a significant drag on American GDP.
So, for all these reasons— it is an abuse of the a local government's police power to make it illegal to build apartment buildings.
It's a pain that I'd have to appear before the zoning board to get a variance for a larger garage on my property, but the alternatives are far worse, I think, and I like the idea that fellow city residents are the ones deciding our zoning and variance process.
What concretely do you propose to effect a fix for the problem that you see?
In other words, it will always be this way. Life is a competition for resources and genetic legacy, there are always going to be winners and losers.
>wealthy may ignore social problems
Yes, that's one of the best parts of being wealthy. Being able to enjoy life without constantly worrying about other people's problems.
>And it's likely a significant drag on American GDP.
Doubtful. Silicon Valley is pretty segregated and does pretty damn well GDP-wise.
>it is an abuse of the a local government's police power to make it illegal to build apartment buildings.
Zoning laws are police abuse? That's one I haven't heard before. You'd want no government intervention then? Can we build miles and miles of structures like the Oakland Ghost Ship in your fantasy society?
I think that we should be able to build miles and miles of apartment buildings that meet fire-safety codes, rather than laws that mandate vast swathes of a region's land are only usable for single-family homes, leading to sprawl and long car commutes.
Just because a society will never be perfectly just doesn't mean the status quo is particularly just— that's the is-ought fallacy. Do you think the state should use its power to ban things you dislike or find aesthetically distasteful, no matter its effects on others, when you're already wealthy and able to build yourself a pleasant life? Because that's the current usage of zoning law in the US.
I see we welcome immigrants sign on the homes of people who have driven out anyone making less then $100,000 a year. It's shocking to see so many want to slam the doors of opportunity and a better life in the face of the less fortunate.
Go have your enclave, but don't ask the state to help pay for your schools, roads, and pension costs while higher education support is massively cut.
That is why so many working class people see "big city" liberals as hypocrites.
>but don't ask the state to help pay for your schools, roads, and pension costs while higher education support is massively cut.
I'm not seeing the connection here.