News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by rf15 on Monday July 24, 2017 @08:45AM (#14837939)
Let's not make this a witch hunt. Yes, the company should be ostracised, but don't ask for every little person remotely involved with them to pay the price of a stupid lead decision.
Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by bachmeier on Monday July 24, 2017 @09:09AM (#14838102)
I don't know much about this particular case, so I don't have an opinion on the comments above, but the argument that employees shouldn't be punished for participating in an unethical for-profit scheme doesn't really make sense to me.
Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by rf15 on Monday July 24, 2017 @09:22AM (#14838178)
Well, there is also the question of actual participation: Let's say [A]dam thinks they're not getting enough data and had this stupid idea to fix the problem, bought a bunch of repos when he had the chance, and told programmer [B]en to patch this in, while [C]hloe in another room is working on the website or tweaks the ML algorithm. How much is she at fault and involved here? What about [D]elilah and [E]ric in Support? Blaming them all individually and equally harshly for being associated with [A]dam is not really justifyable.
Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by ben-schaaf on Monday July 24, 2017 @09:22AM (#14838184)
Completely agree, it's the classic Nuremberg defense.
Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by rf15 on Monday July 24, 2017 @09:26AM (#14838223)
This kind of polarised thinking doesn't really work - usually you don't have a choice if the entire system turns because it happens relatively fast and not all implications are completely clear to you in the beginning, and usually the system will also just plain lie to you to appear much less destructive than it is. Also: Then every single American is at fault for Trump? I mean, they let it happen, right? So they must take responsibility.
Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by gotchange on Monday July 24, 2017 @09:55AM (#14838471)
Collective punishment and guilt by association are morally reprehensible but getting everyone off the hook is equally wrong irrespective of their rank in the food chain.

I am not saying that you necessarily advocated for this position in your comment but I just felt the need to make my point clear.

Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by ben-schaaf on Monday July 24, 2017 @10:55AM (#14838910)
Of course you can't paint all the employees guilty and leave it at that, that's not what the Nuremberg defence means. If an employee knowingly acts malicious under orders from their boss, then they are just as accountable.

To be clear I'm not advocating a witch hunt, but saying all employees are innocent because they were following their bosses orders is a Nuremberg defence.

Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by rf15 on Monday July 24, 2017 @11:04AM (#14839004)
I know - my comments were more about the initial demand, and it's a little bit of a misunderstanding that people immediately compared it to me trying to invalidate the nuremberg trials.
Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by kazagistar on Monday July 24, 2017 @11:17AM (#14839122)
If programming were an engineering proffesion, each engineer would be responsible for ensuring that the code they worked on was ethical at the potential cost of their license. It isn't of course, but there is nothing unusual about demanding personal responsibility for social implications from individual employees like that.
Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by gotchange on Monday July 24, 2017 @09:45AM (#14838368)
What makes you think that that the coverage of this event to be unbalanced and vindictive?

I think that we all agree that this event should be documented and reported objectively as it's newsworthy proved by this very article here and it deserves a mention in a subsection on their Wiki entry.

Re:How a VC-funded company is undermining the open-source co... by HelloNurse on Monday July 24, 2017 @09:26AM (#14838211)
The effectiveness of this line of defense hasn't improved since the Nuremberg Trials. And the directly responsible committers are not "every little person".