Re:Raising a Truly Bilingual Child
by pbhjpbhj on Sunday July 23, 2017 @05:00AM
(#14831462)
In French doesn't the negation get partially swallowed sometimes/often, like "il trouve pas" or is that my poor listening?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Raising a Truly Bilingual Child
by umanwizard on Sunday July 23, 2017 @02:30PM
(#14833655)
“Swallowed” isn’t the right way to describe it. That implies that in people’s heads they think they’re saying “ne” but they don’t because they’re speaking too fast, or whatever.
In reality, “pas” (without “ne”) is simply the unmarked, natural way of forming negation in spoken French. The extra “ne” is relatively uncommon (except in writing which is a whole different ball game) and normally signifies a slightly higher level of formality.
As an aside, “pas” was originally a noun meaning “step” (and still does have this meaning) – quite an odd etymology for a negative particle!
In spoken French it's definitely on its way out, effectively leaving only "pas" as a single negative particle. It's a good example of what is called the Jespersen's Cycle
Re:Raising a Truly Bilingual Child
by Manishearth on Sunday July 23, 2017 @02:00PM
(#14833487)
Yes, however my French is primarily writing/reading, so I personally never do that.
In fact my pronunciation is horrible and I struggle to understand spoken French (this is improving).