Yeh, solid point. All the current sites are highly active because of their broad domain overview.
And, if I were a betting man, I wouldn't bet against StackOverflow's monthly 7 million users. In fact I would be betting on the statistics Stack Exchange site launching in the next couple of weeks and getting critical mass very very quickly.
MetaOptimize is building on top of an existing well-targeted community like MathOverflow did. Really, just like you did originally with your and Jeff's blog communities. AskMetafilter is successful because it was an outlet for an existing community — it wasn't attempt to start a new one.
Area51 is scavenging small clumps of people that happen to overlap with your existing main sites. That your sites are so QA-focused makes it very difficult for an actual community to grow within it — there's no outlet for chat and friend-making, for fucks sake even your moderation site is the same QA format! At least you've integrated it a bit more so that Meta isn't a completely separate community with it's own account system…
I agree. I would see these new stackexchange clones every other day at /r/machinelearning. It would have hurt the ML community if all of the sites started competing for eyeballs.
Anyway thanks a lot for the initiative. I wish you all the best.
machine learning (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/7607/machine-learn...)
NLP (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/2761/natural-langu...)
statistical analysis (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/33/statistical-ana...)
data mining (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/4229/data-mining)
AI (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/6607/artificial-in...)
This niching is completely wrongheaded. As I wrote in a comment on this blog post, the last thing we need is for ML people, NLP practitioners, and statisticians to communicate less. The fact that these groups attend different conferences is a BUG not a feature. My site was designed so that these adjacent fields can crosspolinate information.
As we’ve learned from StackOverflow, it’s better to pick a broad topic and have a lot of experts in one place, communicating and helping with each other’s problems.