News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did StackOverFlow just lose it to MetaOptimize? And is it... by bravura on Friday July 02, 2010 @06:28PM (#1482582)
The main reason I launched my Q+A site is because, if Area 51 had their druthers, they would have fragmented the community into five niches:

machine learning (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/7607/machine-learn...)

NLP (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/2761/natural-langu...)

statistical analysis (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/33/statistical-ana...)

data mining (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/4229/data-mining)

AI (http://area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/6607/artificial-in...)

This niching is completely wrongheaded. As I wrote in a comment on this blog post, the last thing we need is for ML people, NLP practitioners, and statisticians to communicate less. The fact that these groups attend different conferences is a BUG not a feature. My site was designed so that these adjacent fields can crosspolinate information.

As we’ve learned from StackOverflow, it’s better to pick a broad topic and have a lot of experts in one place, communicating and helping with each other’s problems.

Re:Did StackOverFlow just lose it to MetaOptimize? And is it... by ErrantX on Friday July 02, 2010 @07:04PM (#1482681)
As we’ve learned from StackOverflow, it’s better to pick a broad topic and have a lot of experts in one place, communicating and helping with each other’s problems

Yeh, solid point. All the current sites are highly active because of their broad domain overview.

Re:Did StackOverFlow just lose it to MetaOptimize? And is it... by spolsky on Friday July 02, 2010 @07:08PM (#1482690)
I don't think that it's a foregone conclusion that Area51 generates niche sites, just because it generates niche site proposals. I for one believe that it's the big blockbuster stackoverflow-size sites that will actually make it to the end of the Area 51 process and will actually get created.

And, if I were a betting man, I wouldn't bet against StackOverflow's monthly 7 million users. In fact I would be betting on the statistics Stack Exchange site launching in the next couple of weeks and getting critical mass very very quickly.

Re:Did StackOverFlow just lose it to MetaOptimize? And is it... by blasdel on Saturday July 03, 2010 @01:44AM (#1483357)
Not without an existing community to build off of you won't. You'll fail miserably. The people in the Area51 proposals are generally meeting there for the first time — they didn't know each other already.

MetaOptimize is building on top of an existing well-targeted community like MathOverflow did. Really, just like you did originally with your and Jeff's blog communities. AskMetafilter is successful because it was an outlet for an existing community — it wasn't attempt to start a new one.

Area51 is scavenging small clumps of people that happen to overlap with your existing main sites. That your sites are so QA-focused makes it very difficult for an actual community to grow within it — there's no outlet for chat and friend-making, for fucks sake even your moderation site is the same QA format! At least you've integrated it a bit more so that Meta isn't a completely separate community with it's own account system…

Re:Did StackOverFlow just lose it to MetaOptimize? And is it... by TalGalili on Saturday July 03, 2010 @11:37AM (#1483915)
I also wonder when will they incorporate more "social network" features into SO. I feel how it is needed...
Re:Did StackOverFlow just lose it to MetaOptimize? And is it... by kunjaan on Saturday July 03, 2010 @01:30AM (#1483344)
>if Area 51 had their druthers, they would have fragmented the community into five niches

I agree. I would see these new stackexchange clones every other day at /r/machinelearning. It would have hurt the ML community if all of the sites started competing for eyeballs.

Anyway thanks a lot for the initiative. I wish you all the best.