News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swedish pirate party to run the pirate bay from inside th... by anigbrowl on Friday July 02, 2010 @05:25PM (#1482424)
I'm not offended (or motivated to downvote) by your claims, but after following your links it seems like quite weak sauce, and some more substantive documentation is needed.

Certainly, there seems to be connections between the Pirate Bay/Party and this guy who has an unsavory past and connections to an unpleasant political fringe. But how strong and how current are these connections? One might argue in turn that the RIAA is the lobbying arm of an industry which has had more than its share of dubious characters, both ethically and politically. Or point out that TPB was the main distribution vector (and helped to promote) a Swedish anti-fascist film last year - 'Nasty Old People', IIRC. Or we can get into the perennial internet argument about whether it's ethical to use PCs because IBM sold punch-card machines to Hitler's government.

I'm not saying your point is wrong, but that it needs to be backed up with more context than a simple allegation of guilt by association. I've worked for companies that were later found to have been breaking the law, but that doesn't make me a participant in their illegal activity.

There are no comments on this comment yet.