Heterosexual male, picked all four left, although only the first was obvious for me.
I think I'm not answering the right question though. Looking at the first picture, I'd agree that the left face is more attractive, but I'm more attracted to the face on the right. Weird distinction.
I'm also a bit jaded by a quote I heard a long time ago along the lines of "experimental psychology is really the psychology of the 18-year old freshman psych student."
I'm fairly surprised that the actual results were so skewed. And my wife's feelings are hurt because I tell her she's attractive and now she knows my taste is abnormal.
I found the first girl on the right definitely more attractive, but I generally find slightly more masculine looking women more attractive, even though I'm quite heterosexual. I guess most men just like more feminine looking women because of some kind of dominance instinct. (Though it could also just be a flawed study, a statistical fluke of some sort.)
It would be really neat to do a statistically significant test on that.
If heterosexual males and females preferred the left images far more often, it's strange that I would have chosen the right for both. I wonder if these results are typical for my subgroup, and if so, why?
Gotta love having hardwired sexual preferences for a non-reproductive orientation! It's like asking whether you prefer carburetors or fuel injection on your bumper car. :)