That's not my argument. My argument is that there's a reason it's illegal under US law (and presumably in other functioning legal systems): because it has to be illegal for the game theory of vote-per-share corporations to work. Otherwise entering a corporation as a minority shareholder is irrational.
If you abandon the legal system's protection for minority shareholders, you're assuming that you don't need those protections -- that somehow cryptocurrency game theory works differently than the game theory of legal corporations. I suspect that's wrong. But either way, we have to at least be clear about the practical impact of Ethereum's hard fork in order to have the debate.
The software IS law in the world of Etherium. There is a reason they are called "Smart Contracts", instead of "methods" or "functions". They are designed to be binding.
The DAO having a faulty smart contract is akin to someone agreeing to a bad deal. They feel cheated, but there is nothing legally that they can do.
Personally, I believe there should never have been a hard fork. The people that invested in the DAO were stupid to do so.
The token holders of theDao did not approve running of the attacker's contract, since they did not agree to the attacker's contract. At least that's how I interpret it.
Also, the word "contract" is not the same as a contract in law, it's more of a buzzword. They are just programs. So I don't think a program can have legal meaning by itself because it also depends of the semantics of the machine & how it interprets the programs. What happens if the code is correct, but something in the machine is broken?
The rules of the Ethereum virtual machine were altered later. I think the 'fallback function' now has a limit of 23k gas, correct me if I'm wrong, so attacks like these are more difficult, if even possible.
The "attacker" is seen as the "bad guy" so everyone decides to screw him?
It's rather inconsistent to on the one hand claim that "that's just how Ethereum contracts work; the hackers should be allowed to keep those funds" even though those hacks would clearly be illegal under US law, then on the other hand turn around and say "forking the currency like this is wrong because it'd be illegal if this was a company operating under US law".