Re:Peek Behind Bret Victor's Lab at YC HARC
by Pulcinella on Thursday July 20, 2017 @09:47PM
(#14817530)
I would need to know what the actual task is, but isn't that obvious? If I ask adults "What's 2+2" in a language they don't understand and I ask the same question to children in their native language, the children will look smarter than the adults.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
It's nothing at all like that. I already mentioned the Selection task above, it's a very googleable term. It's old and there is yet no theory fully explaining why people fail at it as they do. Pragmatic reasoning schemas are the nearest attempt at an explanation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wason_selection_task
Re:Peek Behind Bret Victor's Lab at YC HARC
by saywatnow on Friday July 21, 2017 @04:03AM
(#14818849)
by serendipity I clicked through on this link and sgentle's link to Kay on McLuhan and the following sentence comes remarkably close to my experience of the two presentations of the Selection task:
> .. the most important thing about any communications medium is that message receipt is really message recovery: anyone who wishes to receive a message embedded in a medium must first have internalized the medium so it can be “subtracted” out to leave the message behind.
(a tangent, but perhaps interesting)