News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How an ex-FBI profiler helped put an innocent man behind ... by vidarh on Thursday July 20, 2017 @08:28PM (#14817275)
The moment in the story where I lost all respect for this profiler was the description of how he insisted a "tell" implied lying. There are no known generic reliable tells for lying and anyone claiming there is are basically disqualifying themselves from being an authority on behaviour.

There are reliable tells that imply "pacifying behaviours" for stress, and those can be useful to pay attention to in order to get people to trip up in interrogations, but there are many possible reasons for that kind of stress, including an interrogation itself being a stressor. But people who try to identify lies based on their theories of such tells without intimately knowing that person in advance generally do no better than chance.

(A good book on the subject, which gives a very sober assessment of what body language can actually reliably tell us vs. where you need to thread carefully is Joe Navarro's "What Every Body is Saying" - Navarro is a former FBI agent and trainer)

There are no comments on this comment yet.