Re:This famous roboticist doesn’t think Elon Musk understand...
by gumby on Thursday July 20, 2017 @12:32AM
(#14810023)
There's nothing "magical" about the human brain, but it's an extremely large, massively parallel device that with a clock speed of about 100 Hz.
When I say "massively parallel" I mean that a human brain (forget rest of nervous system) has about 80 G neurons. Each of which has a fan out between 10^4 and 10^5.
Architecturally this is quite different from a transistorized device with a much faster clock speed but a paucity of interconnect. Now few people say that we need to duplicate the brain (Numenta excepted -- although I have been half of a team that made a new brain and it was fun). After all an automobile does not look like a cheetah nor a plane look like an eagle. But this should give you some idea of the complexity of the problem.
(At Leela we are building something that approaches a more "brain" like computation when compared to, say, deep Q learning, and even for us, the equivalent of 2 M neurons requires about 16 TB of RAM).
When I say "massively parallel" I mean that a human brain (forget rest of nervous system) has about 80 G neurons. Each of which has a fan out between 10^4 and 10^5.
Architecturally this is quite different from a transistorized device with a much faster clock speed but a paucity of interconnect. Now few people say that we need to duplicate the brain (Numenta excepted -- although I have been half of a team that made a new brain and it was fun). After all an automobile does not look like a cheetah nor a plane look like an eagle. But this should give you some idea of the complexity of the problem.
(At Leela we are building something that approaches a more "brain" like computation when compared to, say, deep Q learning, and even for us, the equivalent of 2 M neurons requires about 16 TB of RAM).