Re:Show HN: A Set of Dice That Follows the Gambler's Fallacy
by xg15 on Wednesday July 19, 2017 @03:26PM
(#14807132)
> My friends, who are also CS grads and should know better...
I know this is about being "technically correct" but I'd argue that even if you're pedantic and know the behavior of true randomness, the complaints are justified.
First, "pick a song from a uniform distribution" is an implementation detail, not the use case. The use case is "pick songs in a pleasant, novel order". If the implementer chose to do this using uniform randomness, that's their descision. If that implementation does not fulfill the use case, it's a bug and also their responsibility.
Second, the function is frequently called "shuffle" - so it even gives some hints about the implementation expected. No shuffling algorithm should ever result in duplicates. (except at the beginning and end of playlists)
I know this is about being "technically correct" but I'd argue that even if you're pedantic and know the behavior of true randomness, the complaints are justified.
First, "pick a song from a uniform distribution" is an implementation detail, not the use case. The use case is "pick songs in a pleasant, novel order". If the implementer chose to do this using uniform randomness, that's their descision. If that implementation does not fulfill the use case, it's a bug and also their responsibility.
Second, the function is frequently called "shuffle" - so it even gives some hints about the implementation expected. No shuffling algorithm should ever result in duplicates. (except at the beginning and end of playlists)