Re:UK Government asks: "Which laws would you like to see rep...
by jakehow on Thursday July 01, 2010 @06:35PM
(#1479481)
If it is a rule, it's a rule. There is no reason why every law could not be broken down into one page. Right now ( in the US) we have these massive changes that are encompassing thousands of new rules or modifications to existing rules.
This is a bad idea for the same reason that pushing massive untested changesets into an application would be a bad idea. Incremental, atomic changes that could be revoked is a much better practice on nearly every front (except for maintenance of the power of politicians)
Re:UK Government asks: "Which laws would you like to see rep...
by eru on Thursday July 01, 2010 @09:26PM
(#1479835)
I am wary, that a one page rule would have unintended side effects. Like not reducing the complexity, but making the wording extremely terse instead.
Re:UK Government asks: "Which laws would you like to see rep...
by jakehow on Thursday July 01, 2010 @10:01PM
(#1479898)
Totally agree, it would need to be accompanied by a corresponding change in the culture of governance (and is highly unlikely), but one can wish.
The version control is a very good idea that might actually work in practise. At least from a technical point of view. I don't know whether some people actually prefer the old system of amending.