Also, your argument is specious since it completely ignores the cost of unnecessary medicine performed in order to ward off lawsuits. For example, a lawsuit fearing doctor might order unnecessary tests and procedures with little medical benefit but, but which the doctor can point to in court and say "look, I did the best I could".
2) Humans respond disproportionately to low probability, high cost events. Witness the reaction to "XXX causes cancer", the DC sniper, 9/11, or similar rare events.
So yeah, I'd say fear of lawsuits is a better explanation than the desire to make somebody else $2000 richer.
So, you're 100% certain that the pulmonary specialist is not an owner or an investor at the sleep study facility?
In reality, it is quite common for doctors to own or invest in facilities to which they refer their own patients.
Average health in the town, nothing special about it except the fact that they bill twice as much. They're sending each other referrals like crazy. It's in Texas, so I'm guessing their medical malpractice costs are not above average.
Given those figures, I'd guess that "avoiding liability" is a convienent excuse for running up the bill in many cases. If the laws aren't changing, and the amount of settlements awarded is actually decreasing relative to the cost of care, why is care going up so fast? Why spend more money avoiding liability this year than last year, if the odds of being sued have actually gone down?
Of course, expenses incurred doing better medicine and not screwing up as opposed to reducing liability are probably a good idea.
Meanwhile, medical costs are more on the order of 2 trillion and have been increasing by over 15 % a year for the last 10 years.
I don't think liability is really the main cost driver here. I'd look at profits first. $2k to do a sleep study? How much work could that possibly be? And then they insist on another one? Not to mention the whole PCP -> specialist -> other specialist to get a frickin piece of plastic. Everyone got a piece there.