News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Is Having a Civil War as It Enters a Critical Month by rwmj on Monday July 17, 2017 @01:13PM (#14790491)
If Bitcoin splits, what do you predict would be the effect on holders of bitcoins?

- They have twice as much money (yay!)

- They have twice as much money but the value is split, so it's worth approximately the same.

- One of the branches wins or mostly wins.

- The split does so much damage that some (all?) value of coins is lost.

Re:Bitcoin Is Having a Civil War as It Enters a Critical Month by keyme on Monday July 17, 2017 @01:57PM (#14790854)
My guess is that a split of any initial ratio (even 50-50) will quickly converge to 90%+ of all users on one side. Quickly, as in minutes to hours.

Also, by "users", I don't mean holders. I mean entities that actually transact bitcoin on a daily basis. Exchanges and merchants. They can't afford to lose any time (money) on waiting for their favorite chain to win. They have to use the longest chain (and they are the only ones that matter).

Seeing that there is no way in hell the initial split will be anything worse than 75-25 (against Core), I predict that the price will quickly stabilize on the markets after the initial panic (which is already underway, IMHO).

The value of "bitcoin" (the winning side) after the split (and recovery from panic) will have lost an amount equivalent to what "minority coin" is worth at the time (if anything).

Re:Bitcoin Is Having a Civil War as It Enters a Critical Month by Taek on Monday July 17, 2017 @09:44PM (#14793759)
Exchanges and merchants transact... with users. Also, you definitely don't have to use the longest chain. That's one of the key innovations if Bitcoin, you only follow the longest chain that your node sees as valid. At the moment of the split, most nodes will not see the 2x chain as valid, so they will not follow it even if it is the longest chain. But those nodes will keep working.
Re:Bitcoin Is Having a Civil War as It Enters a Critical Month by kbaker on Monday July 17, 2017 @02:52PM (#14791311)
You can look at ETH vs ETH classic to see the effect. Initial huge drop while things get reorganized, then after a long time, with the legacy chain worth 10% of the main chain, with unknown extra value lost due to the split.

This assumes enough hashpower where people can still transact on the legacy chain, and with some sort of replay protection to where exchanges can safely actually convert the funds to have two separate tradable tokens. Right now that doesn't exist, so exchanges won't touch it. This is a huge reason why Bitcoin Unlimited was a non-starter.

Re:Bitcoin Is Having a Civil War as It Enters a Critical Month by nul_byte on Tuesday July 18, 2017 @10:43AM (#14796887)
I really have not being paying much attention to crypto (apart from seeing the odd thing on reddit and here).

I hold some BTC and ETH, is it a case that what I have is no longer holding the value I believed it has?

Re:Bitcoin Is Having a Civil War as It Enters a Critical Month by buckie on Monday July 17, 2017 @01:26PM (#14790610)
I think this is the problem or at least what permits what we're seeing. If coin holders had to choose a side for their coins to be found on I bet things would be rather different. However, this is in no one's financial interest.

Right now, the risk isn't that high as the worst case (added uncertainty breaks bitcoin completely) is very unlikely. Instead, (a) one side wins you still have the same amount of coins or (b) both sides win and you probably have +2x the value long term.