News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethereum Plunges 20% by chii on Sunday July 16, 2017 @07:46PM (#14784709)
i keep hearing that the blocksize can be increased without difficulty. But why isn't it? What are the problems you're not saying about doing this?
Re:Ethereum Plunges 20% by gravypod on Sunday July 16, 2017 @08:06PM (#14784769)
Both versions of BitCoin would exist concurrently if this change was made. One network would be using 1 MB block sizes (the people who didn't take the update from the devs) and the other group using 4 MB block sizes (the people who updated their wallet/mining rigs).

Unfortunately "most" users want larger block sizes to decrease wait times while "most" miners want block sizes to stay at 1 MB so difficulty is doesn't increase, all their ASICs still work, and so they get more money (IIRC people can pay for fast-lane processing).

If the devs pushed the 4 MB change the miners wouldn't move and because of this no transactions on the 4 MB bitcoin would actually work. If the devs don't push 4 MB then all of the users leave to another coin and bitcoin drops in value.

Talk about rock and a hard place.

Re:Ethereum Plunges 20% by jgord on Sunday July 16, 2017 @08:34PM (#14784870)
I think miners acting in their self interest would realize that a much larger number of transactions with smaller fees would result in a larger total fees profit per block solve.

Almost all of their resources would be the same - the vast majority of their electricity bill is spent solving the block hash compute problem, the resources to actually process the transactions and send them are small compared to that.

The basic logic holds, that you cant make money if nobody uses Bitcoin.

Re:Ethereum Plunges 20% by Fej on Sunday July 16, 2017 @11:04PM (#14785394)
But you can make money if nobody uses Bitcoin. Such is speculation.
Re:Ethereum Plunges 20% by jgord on Sunday July 16, 2017 @11:12PM (#14785422)
for a while at least, yes : ]
Re:Ethereum Plunges 20% by jgord on Sunday July 16, 2017 @08:29PM (#14784845)
The max blocksize is a code constant, so it requires upgrading software on a lot of machines to a version with the fix, which is incompatible with older versions. Called a "hard fork", meaning a fork in the blockchain - because older software would see those new larger blocks as invalid.

The blocksize has been increased in the past, without major upheaval. There is some risk, but staying with outdated software forever also has its own risk.

We should make the single hardfork count - eg. an agreed schedule to increase blocksize over time to keep pace with moores law was proposed as a way to avoid future recurring hardforks.

I think the issue is to manage the risk well - telegraph and explain the roadmap so there is certainty for all parties. Gain consensus, but understand perfect consensus is impossible.

Re:Ethereum Plunges 20% by bfu on Monday July 17, 2017 @08:30AM (#14787860)
I think the fear is that if you can increase block size from 1MB to 4MB, why not 40MB, or 400 GB. At some point someone will ask:

How big should we make the block so that only big banks with specialized hardware can afford to run the bitcoin network.