News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Next-Generation GPU-Powered EC2 Instances (G3) by jnwatson on Friday July 14, 2017 @07:41AM (#14769025)
No. Making a GPU resistant algorithm is hard. Ethereum is ASIC but not GPU resistant.
Re:Next-Generation GPU-Powered EC2 Instances (G3) by dkersten on Friday July 14, 2017 @08:19AM (#14769188)
Why is that? I understand that GPU's have a ton more memory than an ASIC, but couldn't you attach a huge amount of RAM or something to your ASIC (kinda like how GPU's work)?
Re:Next-Generation GPU-Powered EC2 Instances (G3) by imtringued on Friday July 14, 2017 @08:40AM (#14769293)
Those ASICs will cost as much as GPUs or more for the same amount of performance.
Re:Next-Generation GPU-Powered EC2 Instances (G3) by dkersten on Friday July 14, 2017 @09:43AM (#14769696)
Thanks!

Although, since an ASIC is application specific, couldn't you pack more cores (since you can ignore the circuitry that you don't need) or otherwise optimise for the application? If you can do more work, or do the same amount of work with less energy, then it could still be worth it.

I am obviously ignoring a rather important factor: its unlikely a "small" player could make a more performant ASIC than a "big" player like the GPU vendors, who have invested billions into building high performance hardware in a cost effective way. I'm not really asking "why don't people do this", but rather asking if its possible at all given a big enough budget.