News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog by nl on Friday July 14, 2017 @03:35AM (#14768195)
This is so true.

On HN a few months ago I came across someone claiming that web search was fine before Google and the only reason Google got popular was superior marketing.

I found that so completely shocking to me that someone didn't remember how bad it was. Then I realised that was nearly 20 years ago, and it was really only 7 years or so when search was bad.

I'd never felt so old before.

Re:What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog by pluma on Friday July 14, 2017 @08:10AM (#14769144)
I can't be the only person to remember using search aggregators (aka "meta search engines") because every individual search engine was so bad and incomplete on its own, especially outside the US.

The "major" search engines before Google were Yahoo and Altavista, who were too busy trying to sell you a foggy concept of being "the Internet's start page" to be of any practical use when you actually wanted to find something specific. And of course plenty of people were stuck in their own ridiculous AOL microcosm.

Not only were the search engines lackluster and incomplete, the search results were also simply not very relevant. Often you'd only get good results because there simply wasn't enough content indexed for your queries to be in any way ambiguous but good luck if you were looking for anything you couldn't pin down to one or two very explicit search terms.

Kids these days don't know how good they have it with their Googles and their smartpads.

Re:What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog by Maultasche on Friday July 14, 2017 @06:21PM (#14773679)
Oh yeah, before Google came along I used Metacrawler, which would search about 8 search engines and compiled the results. It was a big improvement over Webcrawler, which I had used previously. Searching was really bad back then compared to now. I remember having to wade through lots of irrelevant search results to find what I wanted.

The moment I discovered Google in early 2000, I dumped Metacrawler and never went back.

Re:What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog by alexvoda on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:50PM (#14779193)
I remember using Yahoo, Altavista, Lycos, Excite, DogPile, and a few others. I also used some meta search engines but I can't remember them.

But I do remember using Copernic.It was a meta search engine application. You had to install this one.

Re:What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog by vidarh on Friday July 14, 2017 @01:05PM (#14771319)
To a lot of us there was a period where it felt like Google was inferior because while it was good, if you understood your space and knew which terms to carefully include/exclude in the search using search operators with Altavista for example, you'd be likely to get a better result. For a while.

But that was based on a web where the amount of information was "small" and of searching within small bubbles we knew well, and spending a lot of time refining searches.

What "made" Google was first making search "good enough" that casual searches would return good results without spending time tuning inclusion/exclusion or figuring out which terms were used for a given subject first. Suddenly search "worked" for a lot of people and instances where it didn't work before, and for a rapidly growing internet population that made figuring out how to make an engine like Altavista work totally pointless.

Altavista was "better" once you had a hyperspecialised set of skills around using Altavista. But that too only lasted until Google had improved their algorithms a bit more combined with people starting to pay attention to SEO. Out went the last niches where the old-style engines could compete.

Re:What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog by nl on Saturday July 15, 2017 @02:34AM (#14775300)
I used altavista from when it was altavista.digital.com. The only time I remember it being better than Google was when Google only spidered the Stanford domain, and slightly later if you knew the page title you were looking for.

Also if you wanted Usenet search before DejaNews.

Re:What libraries lost when they threw out the card catalog by vidarh on Saturday July 15, 2017 @03:05AM (#14775410)
Note that I didn't write that it was better in general. It was briefly better for the subset of users that knew exactly what to search for in their specific niches, until e.g. people got used to SEO and the like.

If you knew from past experience and searches that most people used term X when they wrote about Y, Altavista gave you more precise tools to narrow your search.

The whole point being that a subset of users were blinded by our in depth experience with Altavista into not seeing the advantages of Google as early on - we knew exactly how to work around the limitations.

The problem for Altavista, and advantage for Google, is that this doesn't scale. It takes a lot of effort to expand this to learning how to search in any new subject, and that effort grows dramatically as the amount of indexed pages increases and it becomes harder to find terms that act as good filters. It was only viable for a short period of time when the web was small and most people didn't think about SEO, and as long as we were still conditioned to treat a search engine as something you used for things you couldn't e.g. find in a directory.