Here's the thing. If she had say, 2 shoots in a week, maybe a total of say 8 hours of shooting time, the selection, editing, and styling of those photos could take 3x or 4x as long as the time spent shooting. She would have to be editing constantly.
I've always thought a perfect application for this sort of technology would be a model trained on that particular photographer's style, which goes through a batch of photos and selects the best candidates and then presents the user with a few choices for each photo it selected and styled.
I think the ultimate would be a NAS with this capability embedded. The photographers I have met through her over the years seem savvy about photo tech, but don't generally use online storage solutions or know much more than how to admin a WP site at best. SOHO solution would be ideal imo.
Great work! I'm excited to see where this goes.
It's more likely this will hit consumers hands via an automatically applied 'enhancement' in Google Photos first.
Storage is always a problem with every photographer I have met. They keep stacks of external USB drives or burn archives to DVD. They don't trust or want to use online storage.
A package that provided these models, trainable on that photographer's particular style, with autocropping, watermarking, etc. would sell very well among this group.
At these small numbers, they are more likely to just give away access to the software for free.
If you had a system to:
- batch ingest new photos
- stylize them to your own style
- categorize them
- autoselect candidate photos for final tweaking
- back up final album photos to local storage and S3
- archive to Glacier the rest of the photos from the shoot that will likely never be touched again
You would have a product that I think would be very attractive to professional and semi-professional photographers.
I think you're trying to say professional photographers don't apply tone mapping to single exposures, but that is false. There are times when it's not 'technically proper' to apply tone mapping to a single exposure, but it makes for a better picture.
Really it sounds like you're trying to make a snarky comment referencing how some professional photographers complain about novices over using HDR on flickr. But who cares. You can have a professional quality photograph that uses what some pros think is incorrect tone mapping. Just like how you can have a novice hack together a working professional-level product that many professional engineers think is trash. If it works and meets the criteria, who cares.
14 stops of dynamic range in a single shot (RAW on a modern DSLR) counts in my book.
My point is that with 2005-era DSLRs, I had to use HDR techniques (or strobes) to, say, correctly expose a room and the environment out a window. Shooting into the sun, I'd have to use HDR, polarizers, and/or ND grads to expose both the sky and the foreground. With my D750? I've got 4 stops more dynamic range and the situations where I need HDR have almost all gone away. I can get the same thing from a single RAW exposure.
These days, HDR only seems necessary if you want to have ridiculous tone mapping where you pull in your global highlights to be within a stop or two of your global shadows and still keep the noise levels down.
But to your point... it seems that "HDR" means two different things these days.
1. A tool to expand the dynamic range.
2. A style of tone mapping.
These two things frequently coincide, but there's no reason for #1 to have crazy surreal tones, and #2 frequently comes from a single exposure.
Was there any control for, e.g., the dynamic lighting filter being the factor that carried most of the water, rather than the other manipulations?
FWIW, I did think your tool did a good job finding good compositions within mundane scenes. Looking at the originals, I have to admit that in many or even most of the cases, I wouldn't have spotted the opportunity - which points to an area I can improve my craft.
I'm curious: Is this creatism link what the algorithm considers the best images, or did you manually filter out some of the less good ones?
On the con side: only an AI photo-bot can find and capture the most photogenic scenes in the world.
The method proposed in the paper(https://arxiv.org/abs/1707.03491) is mimicing a photographer's work: From taking the picture(image composition) to post-processing(traditional filter like HDR, Saturation. But also GAN powered local brightness editing).In the end it also picks the best photos(Aesthetic ranking)
Selected comments from professional photographers at the end of paper is very informative. There's also a showcase of model created photos in http://google.github.io/creatism
[Disclaimer: I'm the second author of the paper]